A/HRC/7/12
page 20
prosecuted simply for being smuggled - it specifies that migrants shall not become liable to
criminal prosecution for being the “object” of smuggling - it is significant that irregular entry
remains a criminal offence in many countries.46
59. In contrast with the definition of trafficking, although smuggling can be abusive and
dangerous, its definition does not necessarily denote the occurrence of exploitation or a violation
of human rights. In practice, however, the distinction between the two can be hard to draw and,
as explained above, migrants who initially consent to being smuggled may end up in exploitative
situations.47 Due to the ambiguities in such practices, and not least owing to the proliferation of
networks as a response to ever more restrictive anti-immigration policies, it is particularly
important that States receive irregular migrants perceived to be involved in trafficking and
smuggling practices on an individual basis, investigating to the fullest extent their potential
complicity, and providing for them guarantees of due process.
III. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS FOR THE
PROTECTION OF IRREGULAR MIGRANTS
60. The Special Rapporteur encourages States to view irregular migration as an
administrative offence, reversing the trend toward greater criminalization, and to
incorporate the applicable human rights framework into their bilateral and regional
arrangements for managing migration flows and protecting national security interests, as
well as to harmonize their national laws and policies with international human rights
norms. At the core of immigration policies should be the protection of migrants, regardless
of their status or mode of entry. As such, the Special Rapporteur offers the following
recommendations for the formation or reform of regional and bilateral cooperation
mechanisms and agreements, as well as the enhancement of national training and analysis
programmes and policy measures.
Incorporating a human rights framework
61. States should incorporate the applicable human rights framework into their bilateral
and regional arrangements for managing migration flows and protecting national security
interests. Specific attention should be paid to detainees, smuggled migrants, victims of
trafficking, children, women, asylum-seekers and other vulnerable groups. Policies
designed for the readmission and reintegration of returnees should ensure that migrants
seeking international protection are not forcibly returned without guaranteeing their rights
to seek aslyum.
62. States should incorporate international human rights norms into their national
immigration laws and policies. In this context, States who have not yet done so should
ratify the International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers
and Members of Their Families, the first comprehensive international treaty focusing on
46
Smuggling Protocol, article 5, and see Lee, p. 4.
47
Cholewinski, et al., p. 27.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents