A/HRC/27/35
10.
The High Commissioner highlighted the importance of creating an early warning
and rapid response mechanism giving journalists and other media actors immediate access
to the appropriate authorities and to protective measures when they are threatened. Such a
mechanism should be established in consultation with journalists and other media actors
and organizations, and comprise representatives of State bodies dealing with law
enforcement and human rights issues, together with representatives of civil society,
including journalists and media organizations.
11.
Lastly, the High Commissioner emphasized that, most importantly, States must
combat impunity. Every act of violence committed against a journalist that was not
investigated and went unpunished was an open invitation for further violence; ensuring
accountability for attacks against journalists was therefore a key element in preventing
future attacks. She warned that failure to do so could be interpreted as tolerance of or
acquiescence to violence. The investigation and prosecution of all attacks against
journalists through an effective and functioning domestic criminal justice system was
therefore considered imperative, as was remedy for victims. The High Commissioner
referred to good practices, including the creation of special investigative units or
independent mechanisms to carry out investigations, with specialized expertise; specific
protocols and methods of investigation and prosecution; and training for law enforcement
and military personnel, as well as for prosecutors and the judiciary, regarding their
obligations under international human rights law and international humanitarian law, with a
focus on the safety of journalists. The High Commissioner encouraged States to examine,
reinforce and replicate such initiatives.
III. Contributions of panellists
12.
In her introductory remarks, the journalist and panel moderator Ghida Fakhry Khane
underscored the importance of the topic of discussion. She referred to the crucial role that
journalists played in keeping the public informed and in keeping in check the authorities
and institutions that purport to work in the public interest, but also to the high levels of risk,
intimidation, harassment and violence that journalists endured. She described journalism as
a “risky business” in many parts of the world, and recalled that the purpose of the
discussion was to identify good practices in guaranteeing the safety of journalists and ways
to ensure their implementation. She hoped that the discussions could lead to specific
recommendations on what States, international and regional organizations, but also
journalists and media organizations themselves, could do to mitigate the risks for
journalists.
13.
Frank Smyth, journalist and senior adviser for journalist security at the Committee
to Protect Journalists, agreed with the High Commissioner that unequivocal political
commitment from States and combating impunity for attacks against journalists were the
key requirements. Firstly, he emphasized the importance of using clear language when
discussing the safety of journalists. The greatest threat to press freedom, the freedom of
expression and the safety of journalists around the world was the problem of unsolved
journalist murders. He pointed out that more than two out of three journalists killed since
1992 had not stepped on a landmine or been caught in crossfire or victim of an air strike or
a car bomb explosion, but murdered outright in direct reprisal for their reporting. Mr.
Smyth recalled that such acts were crimes by any measure, in any context, and in every
nation around the world. Nonetheless, impunity reigned in nearly nine out of ten cases. The
consistent and alarmingly high rate of impunity for murdering journalists around the globe
was cause for great concern, for the impact of killing one journalist with impunity was to
effectively silence countless more. Secondly, Mr. Smyth deplored the lack of political will
shown by many States in addressing the issue. He referred to the 2014 UNESCO report
5
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents