A/HRC/21/46
2.
Trust
32.
The other mediate aim that the components of the mandate seek to attain is the
promotion of trust. Trust in this context is meant to involve both trust between individuals
and trust of the individuals in State institutions. As the resolution 18/7 puts it, the
expectation is that the implementation of the measures will “restore confidence in the
institutions of the State”. Trust is not the same as mere predictability or empirical
regularity; it involves an expectation of a shared normative commitment and, therefore,
develops out of a mutual sense of commitment to these shared norms and values.
33.
Trusting institutions means knowing and recognizing as valid the values and norms
guiding an institution and deriving from this commitment the assumption that an
institutional set-up resting on such norms and values makes sufficient sense to a sufficient
number of people to motivate their ongoing active support for these institutions and the
compliance with their grounding norms and values. Successful institutions generate a
feedback loop: they make sense to actors who will in turn support them and comply with
what the institutionally defined order prescribes. 16 In conclusion, trusting an institution
amounts to knowing that its constitutive rules, values and norms are shared by its members
or participants and are regarded by them as binding.
34.
To illustrate how transitional justice measures can contribute to (re)building this
type of confidence, it should be noted that prosecutions reaffirm the relevance of the norms
that perpetrators violated, norms which turn natural persons into rights holders. Judicial
institutions, particularly in contexts in which they have traditionally been essentially
instruments of power, show their trustworthiness if they can establish that no one is above
the law. Truth-seeking can foster trust by responding to the anxieties of those whose
confidence was shattered by experiences of violence and/or abuse, who are fearful that the
past might repeat itself. An institutionalized effort to confront the past might be seen by
those who were formerly on the receiving end of violence as an effort in good faith to come
clean, understand long-term patterns of socialization and the distribution of power and
opportunities and thereby initiate a new political project around norms and values that this
time are truly shared. 17 Reparations can foster trust by demonstrating the seriousness with
which institutions now take rights violations. Trust is bolstered when, even under
conditions of scarcity and competition for resources, the State responds to the obligation to
fund programmes that benefit those who were formerly not only marginalized but abused. 18
Finally, vetting of public officials can induce confidence by demonstrating a commitment
to systemic norms governing employee hiring and retention, disciplinary oversight and
prevention of cronyism. 19
35.
Both recognition and trust are preconditions and consequences of justice. A system
of justice unwilling to take seriously the status of its members as holders of rights is
unimaginable. 20 So is one that systematically fails to materialize the commitments to the
16
17
18
19
20
Claus Offe, “How Can We Trust Our Fellow Citizens?” in Democracy and Trust, Mark Warren, ed.,
(Cambridge University Press, 1999), pp. 70–71.
See Pablo de Greiff, “Truth Telling and the Rule of Law” in Telling the Truths: Truth Telling and
Peace Building in Post-Conflict Societies, Tristan Anne Borer, ed. (Notre Dame, University of Notre
Dame, 2006).
See De Greiff, “Justice and Reparations”.
See Pablo de Greiff, “Vetting and Transitional Justice” in Justice as Prevention: Vetting Public
Employees in Transitional Societies, Alexander Mayer-Rieckh and Pablo de Greiff, eds. (Social
Science Research Council, 2007).
As Jürgen Habermas puts the point, “the legal medium as such presupposes rights that define the
status of legal persons as bearers of rights”. Habermas and William Rehg, Between Facts and Norms:
11
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents