A/HRC/19/55
victim(s) was not reported. The majority of the cases involved violations of physical
integrity, including arbitrary detention, torture, ill-treatment, killings, enforced
disappearances and disproportional use of force to break up demonstrations. Other
violations in Africa were judicial in nature, involving broad and often vaguely defined
criminal charges, fines and prison sentences. As in other regions, alleged violations often
happened in the context of peaceful demonstrations, although a marked trend in Africa was
violations by police when breaking up demonstrations, notably through the disproportional
use of force. Participation in public youth forums and issuing of press statements were also
actions that had led to the violations reported.
114. Seven communications were addressed to Governments in the Middle East and
North Africa during the assessed period. Two of the communications were sent to Bahrain,
and another two to Egypt. Men were the victims in all reported cases. Despite the low
number of communications for this region, reported violations were wide-ranging in nature.
The majority represented violations of physical integrity, including enforced
disappearances, arbitrary detention, ill-treatment in detention and disproportional use of
force during demonstrations. Violations of a judicial nature were also reported, including
prison sentences, allegedly fabricated charges and arrests. Some cases involved violations
of psychological integrity, including threats and violence against defenders’ family
members.
115. In addition to these communications, the Special Rapporteur has issued a number of
joint statements with other special procedures pertaining to the situations in several
countries in the Middle East and North Africa during the first half of 2011, including
Bahrain, Egypt, Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (at the time), Syrian Arab Republic and Tunisia.
Together with the Special Rapporteur on the promotion and protection of the right to
freedom of opinion and expression, the Special Rapporteur called on the Syrian Arab
Republic on 15 April 2011 to “immediately release the human rights defenders, journalists
and bloggers, who play a crucial role in monitoring recent events and informing the
public”.
116. In the Europe and Central Asia region, six communications were sent to
Governments during the period, of which two were sent to the Russian Federation. An
important distinction from other regions was that a majority of the victims were women
(four out of six). One case involved a male victim and, in another, the sex of the victim(s)
was not reported. Also in contrast to other regions, the majority of alleged violations in
Europe and Central Asia consisted of raids on and searches of offices, confiscation of
materials, surveillance of defenders’ activities and their organizations’ offices and lengthy
interrogations, and even refusal to allow defenders to travel abroad. There were also alleged
violations of youth and students’ physical integrity, including physical assaults, excessive
use of force during demonstrations and arbitrary detention. There was one case involving
violations of psychological integrity and one case of criminalization of defenders’ activities
following peaceful protests. One case involved violations of a judicial nature, more
specifically prison sentences. In five of the cases, State actors were the alleged perpetrators,
notably police, while non-State actors were the alleged perpetrators in one case.
IV. Conclusions and recommendations
117. The Special Rapporteur is very concerned at the extraordinary risks that these
groups of defenders face due to their work in defence of human rights. Most of these
risks not only directly affect their physical integrity and that of their family members,
but also include the abusive use of legal frameworks against them and the
criminalization of their work. The Special Rapporteur is also extremely concerned at
reports received indicating that State actors, including Government officials, State
19
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents