A/HRC/12/48
page 44
164. The Mission gathered first-hand information with regard to the situation in Israel and in
the West Bank by conducting telephone interviewees with victims, community representatives,
local authorities, members of NGOs and experts; by hearing testimonies from victims, witnesses
and experts from Israel and from the West Bank at the public hearings in Geneva; and by holding
meetings and private interviews both in Amman and in Geneva.
165. The Mission’s efforts in this regard were partially thwarted because of restrictions on the
freedom of movement of some of the people that the Mission wished to interview. The Mission
was not able to meet as planned the Palestinian Minister of Justice, Dr. Ali al-Khashan, in
Amman, as he was not allowed by Israel to leave the West Bank. The Mission was also unable to
meet Ms. Khalida Jarrar, a member of the Palestinian Legislative Council, who is subject to a
travel ban by Israel (see chap. XXII). It held a teleconference with her. A Palestinian witness at
the Geneva public hearings, Mr. Shawan Jabarin, had to be heard by videoconference as he is
also subject to a travel ban by Israel.
A note on the public hearings
166. The purpose of the public hearings, which were broadcast live, was to enable victims,
witnesses and experts from all sides to the conflict to speak directly to as many people as
possible in the region as well as in the international community. The Mission is of the view that
no written word can replace the voice of victims. While not all issues and incidents under
investigation by the Mission were addressed during the hearings, the 38 public testimonies
covered a wide range of relevant facts as well as legal and military matters. The Mission had
initially intended to hold hearings in Gaza, Israel and the West Bank. However, denial of access
to Israel and the West Bank resulted in the decision to hold hearings of participants from Israel
and the West Bank in Geneva.
167. Participants in the hearings were identified in the course of the Mission’s investigations,
and had either first-hand experience or information or specialized knowledge of the issues under
investigation and analysis. In keeping with the objectives of the hearings, the Mission gave
priority to the participation of victims and people from the affected communities. Participants
took part in the hearings on a voluntary basis. Some individuals declined to participate for fear of
reprisal. The Mission received expressions of gratitude from participants, as well as members of
the affected communities, for having provided an opportunity to speak publicly of their
experiences.
C.
Assessment of information
168. In establishing its findings, the Mission sought to rely primarily and whenever possible on
information it gathered first-hand, including through on-site observations, interviews and
meetings with relevant persons. Information produced by others, including reports, affidavits and
media reports, was used primarily as corroboration.
169. The section of the report on the Gaza Strip is based on first-hand information gathered and
verified by the Mission. To assess the situation in Israel and in the West Bank, the Mission had
to make comparatively greater use of information produced by others for the reasons explained
above. These sections too, however, include first-hand information directly gathered and verified
by the Mission.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents