A/HRC/21/51
human rights field presences to promote dissemination and bring together relevant
stakeholders. Proposals aimed at creating more institutionalized and systematic follow-up
included the establishment of a dedicated unit in the Special Procedures Branch to
document follow-up efforts in order to create an institutional memory of best practices. It
was observed that dialogue between States and mandate holders should be enhanced and
that the preparation of follow-up reports was currently hampered by a lack of
responsiveness from States. The point was made that follow-up was not the exclusive
preserve of mandate holders and that national mechanisms for follow-up and assessment of
the implementation rate of recommendations should be established. Non-governmental
organizations, national human rights institutions and United Nations agencies were invited
to contribute to such processes.
33.
Noting that follow-up in the United Nations system was generally weak, mandate
holders discussed the lack of time and resources in that area. It was noted that mandate
holders could strengthen their cooperation with human rights treaty bodies and the
universal periodic review, and build on each other’s recommendations, observations and
conclusions. Better coordination across mechanisms would facilitate engagement with
United Nations country teams and enhance their ability to follow up on recommendations.
Several mandate holders referred to the importance of communications and the need to
have a more systematic approach to this crucial area of work. Ways to make these a more
powerful tool, including through follow-up, were also discussed.
34.
The mandate holders were briefed on the outcome of a study on the protection
impact of United Nations human rights field presences, Influence on the Ground,3 prepared
over a two-year period, highlighting country-specific case studies and based on inputs from
nearly 400 respondents, including State actors, human rights staff and civil society
organizations. The study indicated that protection is best advanced through a multifaceted
strategy, including monitoring through presence, advocacy, diplomacy and technical
cooperation. Maintaining a dialogue with the State is crucial, as is the capacity-building of
local civil society. The cooperation of human rights monitors with authorities has a
significant dissuasive effect and prevents violations, particularly where the presence on the
ground was considered credible and legitimate. Examples of strategic collaboration
between special procedures and field presences were identified. The visits and
communications of special procedures provide a “louder voice” when highlighting
concerns, which is particularly valuable for smaller field presences. It is important for
special procedures to visit rural areas and communities, engage with local civil society
actors and thoroughly consider how mission reports may be of use for a variety of
stakeholders.
35.
The mandate holders welcomed the study and noted that the protection of witnesses
and sources must always be a priority concern. The national staff members of United
Nations human rights field presences may be at more risk than international staff. Some
mandate holders observed that there was a need for capacity-building with regard to human
rights mechanisms, including special procedures, among field staff. The mandate holders
recognized the crucial role that field presences play in promoting follow-up, and that the
special procedures and field presences had distinct independent roles. Maintaining this
distinction and the independence of mandate holders was essential and would help to avoid
politically delicate situations for United Nations personnel in the field. They also pointed to
the complementary roles of OHCHR field presences, other parts of the United Nations on
the ground and local civil society in addressing human rights issues.
3
Liam Mahoney and Roger Nash, Influence on the Ground (Brewster, Fieldview Solutions, 2012).
11
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents