A/HRC/15/18
6.
Administration of justice
49.
In a meeting with the Department of Justice, the members were informed that the
Department’s Civil Rights Office runs cases on hate crimes and oversees civil rights
legislation. The Office carries out outreach activities in the community to inform people
about their civil rights; when it detects an employer that is systematically discriminating
against a racial group it files a case against it. The Office also receives complaints of
discrimination from individuals. There are Civil Rights Offices in the different Government
agencies and they work together and coordinate efforts.
50.
According to information contained in the 2007 periodic report of the United States
(CERD/C/USA/6), to which the members were referred by the Department of State, in
2004, 3.2 per cent of males of African descent, 1.2 per cent of Hispanic males, and
0.5 per cent of white males in the country were incarcerated in state or federal prisons.
Distributions were similar among the female population – the rate for African American
females was more than two times higher than the rate for Hispanic females and four times
higher than the rate for white females. Overall, the prison population was estimated to be 41
per cent African American, 34 per cent white, 19 per cent Hispanic, and 6 per cent other or
two or more races.
51.
In meetings with NGOs, the members were informed that the overrepresentation of
people of African descent in the United States as subjects of the criminal justice system and
their disproportionately high rate of incarceration compared with the white population is of
great concern and demonstrates structural discrimination against them. They were informed
that women of African descent are three times more likely to be imprisoned than white
women, while men of African descent are six and a half times more likely to be imprisoned
than white men. The members were informed that at any one time 11 per cent of all men of
African descent in the United States between the ages of 30 and 34 are behind bars.
52.
One explanation given of the disproportionately high incarceration rate for people of
African descent was the discriminatory application of laws. Discrimination was identified
by NGOs in terms of perpetrators as well as victims. According to them, black perpetrators
are much more likely to be convicted than white perpetrators, and they tend to be punished
more severely. Furthermore, it is likely that there will be a difference in convictions and
punishment depending on the race or colour of the victim, with generally lower sentences in
cases where the victim is black as compared to cases involving white victims. The
discriminatory application of laws was illustrated to the members by way of the application
of the laws against illegal drug use. Whereas the available evidence shows that people of
African descent use illegal drugs at approximately the same rate as white people, they are
10 times more likely, on a per capita basis, to go to prison for drug-related offences. An
NGO informed the members that the application of some laws that seem race neutral tend
to contribute to disproportionately high rates of incarceration for people of African descent.
For example, under United States federal law, possession of 5 grams of crack cocaine (a
drug associated in the public mind with African Americans) triggers a mandatory minimum
sentence of five years in prison. It takes 100 times as much powder cocaine (500 grams) to
trigger the same mandatory five-year sentence. Although African Americans constitute
about 12 per cent of the United States population, more than 80 per cent of those prosecuted
under the crack cocaine mandatory minimum laws are of African descent.
53.
This same disparity was indicated in other areas of criminal law. For example, more
than 2,500 persons are currently serving a life sentence without the possibility of parole or
release for crimes committed when they were less than 18 years old. The members were
informed that the rate of African Americans serving this sentence is more than 10 times
higher than that of whites. The process of criminalization of children from very early
childhood and the higher percentage of children of African descent placed in adult facilities
is negatively influencing the present protection of the rights of children and their future
14
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents