A/HRC/36/43
particularly vulnerable to exploitation and a primary barrier to ensuring them access to
justice is the kafala system of labour sponsorship, by which migrant workers are required to
obtain sponsorship from their employers in order to live and work in the country. Domestic
migrant workers are among the most vulnerable and can face specific barriers to gaining
access to justice and remedy, including severe restrictions on their freedom of movement,
such as passport confiscation and an inability to leave their work premises, and a
dependence on their employers for retaining regular migration status.
2.
Self-identification and lack of trust in the justice system
25.
The relationship between potential victims and offenders can sometimes be
contradictory. Some persons subjected to contemporary forms of slavery would often not
see themselves as victims of exploitation and abuse. Migrant workers, for example, who
had some knowledge of the situation that they were entering, may not want to be labelled as
victims, but be provided with another job and better working conditions. Also, if the
perpetrator is a family member, they may not be willing to be labelled as victims or to press
charges, because of emotional ties. Furthermore, victims who belong to a group of people
that has suffered discrimination and exclusion over generations and live in societies where
slavery crimes are embedded in traditional beliefs and customs, would often not identify
themselves as victims due to the normalization of such practices.
26.
Persons subjected to contemporary forms of slavery often do not have confidence in
law enforcement and judicial bodies. They often consider them to be corrupt or fear they
will be discriminated against or revictimized. Furthermore, the fact that legal processes tend
to be prolonged and complex exacerbates their distrust of the legal system. Systemic
discrimination against people of “low” caste, indigenous people, migrants and other
minorities in wider society and corruption among law enforcement, coupled with victims’
concerns over their particular situation (e.g. irregular status), feed into a general distrust of
the police among victims and a perception that law enforcement agencies and courts exist
to protect the wealthy and powerful.23
B.
Practical barriers
27.
Contemporary forms of slavery often take place in areas that are isolated and not
easily accessible. This poses particular challenges to the identification of victims by the
authorities as well as practical barriers to victims for accessing justice. The informal
employment of workers in a range of economic activities and the fact that exploitation often
occurs in hidden, inaccessible workplaces pose challenges to the identification of victims
and their access to justice; informal employment is widespread in agriculture, small and
medium enterprises, domestic work, among other services. 24 Furthermore, physical
accessibility to justice institutions is a barrier encountered by victims, and the centralization
of legal and administrative systems prevents victims from rural or remote areas from
gaining access to such mechanisms. Thus, in many cases, victims exploited in places far
from the main urban areas have little or no possibilities to gain access to specialized support
services. Child victims in particular face enormous barriers in gaining accessing to justice.
28.
Persons subjected to contemporary forms of slavery belong to groups in society that
are marginalized and economically disadvantaged; they are exploited for their labour and
paid low wages, not paid for their work, or their salaries are withheld; they are
economically dependent on those who exploit them and this situation poses financial
constraints in considering or attempting to gain access to justice. Pursuing criminal justice
and participating in the procedure often involves significant expenses that victims cannot
afford, including court and other filing fees, legal fees, expenses for gathering documents,
23
24
Submissions to the Special Rapporteur from the organizations ASI and the Global Alliance Against
Traffic in Women.
See ILO, Hard to see, harder to count: Survey guidelines to estimate forced labour of adults and
children (Geneva, 2012). Available from www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---ed_norm/--declaration/documents/publication/wcms_182096.pdf.
9
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents