A/HRC/11/37
recommendations, including those in paragraph 82, would compel the Chinese authorities
to revisit and review some issues affecting the Tibetan people, including Order No. 5,
issued by the State Council of China, that interferes in an ancient religious procedure and
tradition of the confirmation of reincarnates of Tibetan Buddhism, and ending the “strike
hard” campaign and education programmes that forced Tibetans to denounce their spiritual
leader.
548. In a joint statement, the Society for Threatened Peoples and Reporters without
Borders noted that one of the many recommendations rejected by China concerned granting
access to Tibetan areas, including for OHCHR and other United Nations bodies. It believed
that this position contradicted China’s pledges and commitments to the Council. It urged
the Chinese authorities to open Tibetan areas for visits, welcomed the authorities’ intention
to invite the High Commissioner in response to the March 2008 request, and urged China to
respond positively to a follow-up visit of the Special Rapporteur on freedom of religion and
belief.
549. Mouvement contre le racisme et pour l’amitié entre les peuples, in a joint statement
with Interfaith International and the Asian Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Network, deeply
regretted the fact that the majority of recommendations had not been accepted by China,
including for the resumption of dialogue between the Government of China and
representatives of the Dalai Lama. They believed that the present impasse had arisen after
the rejection by the Chinese authorities of the requested memorandum on genuine
autonomy for Tibetan people of 2007. They recommended that the authorities seriously
engage with the Dalai Lama’s representatives, as urged by the Secretary-General, and
introduce laws and regulations in accordance with the regional ethnic autonomy law.
550. Human Rights Watch listed the human rights issues on which China had rejected
every recommendation. It drew attention to paragraphs 70, 71 and 104 of the report
containing assertions that were manifestly removed from reality, noting the continued
suppression of any reference to the Beijing massacre of peaceful protestors of 3 and 4 June
1989; to the fact that an individual faced State charges for having compiled a list of names
of children killed during the 2008 Sichuan earthquake; that the country’s once most
prominent lawyer had disappeared for over six months after having been taken into
custody; and that just a week earlier, more than 15 prominent human rights defenders had
been victims of arbitrary disbarment on account of the sensitive nature of the cases they had
represented. Human Rights Watch believed that China seemed to equate any expression of
concern over the situation in Tibetan areas with attempts to politicize the issue.
551. The China Society for Human Rights Studies noted that the All-China Women’s
Federation was working on a draft law concerning domestic violence, and hoped that it
would be adopted soon. In a recent report, the China Society had expressed concern about
the livelihood of migrant workers. Its recommendations had aroused the Government’s
attention. The Society had carried out a project with OHCHR on civil society participation
in the work of treaty bodies and hoped that China would continue to cooperate with
OHCHR and consider future concrete technical cooperation projects.
4.
Concluding remarks of the State under review
552. China thanked all for their support and encouragement. The Government of China
would study carefully the comments and recommendations made by some countries and
non-governmental organizations. China welcomed well-intentioned criticisms and
constructive recommendations, but was resolutely against any assault or allegation out of
political motive or prejudice, or fabrication of lies.
553. China wished to set the record straight. In Tibet, China had abolished, 50 years
earlier, dark theocratic feudal serfdom, sparking historic socio-economic progress there.
GE.09-16766
141
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents