A/HRC/40/CRP.1
Furthermore, the Petroleum Act (2012) stipulates that oil-related documentation held
by the Government shall as far as possible be made publicly available and provides for
regular public reporting by the Government and other parties, including on payments made
to the Government and data on oil revenues and relevant details of petroleum agreements
(Exploration and Production Sharing Agreements, EPSA). 1039 This law also lays down key
regulations on environmental protection and compensation for harms suffered by local
inhabitants and negative impacts on local communities.1040 The Petroleum Act also
establishes a National Petroleum and Gas Commission, which inter alia carries out important
supervisory functions on behalf of the Government, and ensure that petroleum agreements
are in line with the law.1041
The ARCSS and the R-ARCSS replicate several of the above-mentioned provisions,
and lay down deadlines for their implementation, following the expiration of the PreTransitional Period of eight months (from the signing of the R-ARCSS). For example the RARCSS in Articles 4.8.1.1 and 4.8.1.2 calls for implementation of the Petroleum Revenue
Management Act, and the closure of any petroleum revenue accounts not established under
the Act, within three months of the start of the Transition period. The R-ARCSS also instructs
the authorities to expedite the operationalization of Future Generations Fund and the Oil
Revenue Stabilization Account and review and audit allocations and transfers of the two
percent and three percent made to oil producing states since 2011.1042 Significantly, and as
will be further discussed below, the R-ARCSS also calls for the review and transformation
of both the national oil company Nilepet and the National Petroleum and Gas Commission,
and to “empower them to exercise their responsibilities as stated in the Amended Constitution
and Law”.1043
g) Implementation or lack thereof
Despite the existence of the above-mentioned strong legal safeguards, and the fact that
both the Petroleum Act and the Petroleum Revenue Management Act have been in force for
a number of years now, as discussed below, in practice, they have reportedly not been fully
enforced. This non-implementation of legal guidelines drafted and adopted by the South
Sudanese Parliament seriously undermines the rule of law and negates the principles of social
justice underpinning much of the legislation.
The very fact that the R-ARCSS explicitly asks for the implementation of the
Petroleum Revenue Management Acts generally, and for review of the implementation of
several of its provisions suggests that not only has there been little or no implementation thus
far, but also that reliable information on the degree and manner of implementation is
lacking.1044
With regards to the Petroleum Act, there have been consistent reports that key
provisions on transparency have not been implemented: for example, no exploration and
production sharing agreements have been publicized by the Ministry of Petroleum and
Mining, and the Petroleum Registry that should compile such agreements and other data to
make them accessible to the public was not yet created. 1045 Crucially, information on oil
revenues has not been made public by the Ministry. 1046 Such lack of oversight and scrutiny
has reportedly surrounded deals where in particular, the Government has used future oil
revenue as a collateral for loans1047 and other transactions which is has sought to conceal. For
example the Commission was informed that the Government attempted to sign a contract
1039
Petroleum Act (2012), sections 77-80.
Petroleum Act (2012), sections 59-62, 81 and 100(8).
1041 Petroleum Act (2012), Chapter III, sections 9-11.
1042 R-ARCSS, Articles 4.8.1.14.7 and 4.8.1.14.9.
1043 R-ARCSS, Article 4.8.1.14.14.
1044 In addition, the last report by the Joint Monitoring and Evaluation Commission, on the Status of Implementation of the ARCSS,
for the period from 1 April to 30 June 2018, noted in paragraph 45 that little, if any progress had been made in the
implementation of Chapter IV of the ARCSS – “ which concerns Resource, Final and Economic Management”.
1045 David K. Deng, “Oil and Sustainable Peace in South Sudan”, South Sudan Law Society, February 2015, p. 5
1046 Global Witness, “Turning the tide: Building a clean oil sector through South Sudan’s Peace Agreement”, 2015, p. 12;
Confidential Meeting, Juba, 18 December 2018.
1047 Global Witness, “Turning the tide: Building a clean oil sector through South Sudan’s Peace Agreement”, 2015, pp. 5, 13-14.
1040
134
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents