A/HRC/40/CRP.1
The Commission has documented injuries consistent with the above described torture
and cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment. This included scars, ear drum perforation and
muscular-skeletal problems including bone fractures and joint damage indicative of incised
or blunt object wounds, burns, marks or scars consistent with whipping, gunshot wounds,
scars as a result of restraints used on legs, and keloids consistent with untreated skin wounds.
Furthermore, many survivors exhibited psychological symptoms consistent with sustained
torture and detention.
6.
Deaths in Custody
The Commission has documented numerous deaths of detainees while in securityrelated custody. Some were extra-judicially executed, while others died as a result of being
detained in inhuman conditions and denied adequate medical care. The Commission has
identified on the basis of multiple sources at least five named individuals who died while in
NSS custody at the Blue House in 2016 and 2017; however, the overall number of deaths
occurring in security-related custody is clearly significantly higher.
The inadequate provision of food and water described above has led to deaths in
custody at the Giada and Gorum SPLA military detention facilities, and at unofficial NSS
locations in Juba. One witness described how in the Giada military detention facility, “After
four days without food and water, four people in the custody cell died. They removed the
bod[ies] and brought us food and water. It was only when someone was dying that they would
bring us food and water.”433 The Commission was told that there were times at Giada during
which prisoners would die every day.
Gorum appears to be a particularly deadly place to be detained both because of its
conditions in hot, unventilated, crowded containers. One witness told the Commission he
saw at least 10 people die during the three months he was detained at Gorum, while another
described how “In each container there were 20 prisoners. At the end of 5 months there were
only 2 left from the first 20.”434 Another described:
they took me to Gorum about 12-15 miles out of Juba town. This was worst. People
are inside containers with a very small window. I was in a container with many people.
I saw people dying in this container, their bodies are rotten, and you are alive in the
same container. People dying, suffocating in the container and you are with their
bodies.”435
A number of detainees have also died from illnesses as a result of being denied
medical care, including in the NSS Blue House and Riverside facilities, SPLA detention
facilities at Giada, Gorum, and the SPLA garrison prison in Raga. Some of these detainees
had pre-existing conditions which were insufficiently treated while others developed
conditions while in custody. One witness described a detainee who died who “had been
vomiting blood […]. However, the NSS officers ignored [him] and denied him
medication.”436
Detainees have also died as a result of torture inflicted on them at Giada and Gorum
SPLA military detention facilities described above. Additionally, one detainee at the NSS
Blue House reportedly died of kidney damage after he was beaten in detention.
Furthermore, a number of detainees have been extra-judicially executed while in
detention. A number of NSS detainees were killed for misconduct in detention. Further,
another witness told of being among a group of five men who were lined up and shot at the
NSS Blue House. He recounted: “I effectively died so I can’t tell you how long we were at
the NSS Blue House before we were taken to an open field in a place called New Site on the
left side of the road before you get to Bilpham Military Barracks. There, I was buried among
other bodies in a mass grave. Even when I was being buried, however, I had no idea it was
happening because I was unconscious.”437 Later that night, some civilians took the bodies to
the mortuary at the Juba Teaching Hospital where it was discovered that the witness was still
alive. The others, however, did not survive.
433
Witness 786, ERN 101492-101498.
Witness 1117.
435 Witness 1070, ERN 102270-102274.
436 Witness 960, ERN 102089-102111.
437 Witness 993, ERN 102014-102053.
434
67
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents