A/HRC/44/56
B.
Realizing access to effective remedy
40.
While participants addressed the systematic challenges faced in virtually all business
sectors in ensuring access to an effective remedy in line with the third pillar of the Guiding
Principles and the policy recommendations arising from the OHCHR Accountability and
Remedy Project,16 they also discussed challenges specific to certain business contexts, such
as that of digital technologies.
41.
With respect to specific challenges, participants highlighted that, in most cases of
displacement caused by natural disasters, major infrastructure projects such as dams and
agribusiness and extractive industry activities, there was a systematic failure to provide
victims with an effective remedy or compensation. The question of parent companies that
might face expansive liability for the actions of their overseas subsidiary companies was
also raised.
42.
In another session, participants discussed the role of national human rights
institutions and the factors that affect their ability to provide access to remedies for
business-related human rights abuses. Examples were given of the challenges and
limitations that such institutions faced in facilitating access to remedy and of effective
strategies for overcoming them.
43.
The role of mediation in the context of access to remedy was also discussed, with
participants agreeing on the need for specific preconditions to ensure that the mediation
process complements, but does not replace, access to judicial remedies and comply with
effectiveness criteria under principle 31 of the Guiding Principles, including by addressing
power imbalances between the parties.
C.
Leading by example
44.
The programme of work included various sessions on the role of States as economic
actors and on the expectation that States, as primary duty bearers under international human
rights law, should lead by example (A/HRC/32/45, para. 94).
45.
One session was dedicated to the role of public investments and, especially, public
pension funds in scaling up respect for human rights. Information was shared on the
experiences of the councils on ethics of two national pension funds: the Council on Ethics
of the Government Pension Fund Global of Norway and the Council on Ethics of the
Swedish National Pension Funds. The representatives of both councils explained how they
had addressed human rights risks and embedded the Guiding Principles in their work.
Furthermore, they reflected on how to exercise leverage to achieve more human rightscompliant business practices, including through the development of “expectation
documents” on both human rights and children’s rights and on investigations. Participants
noted that such initiatives had great potential to help to mainstream the Guiding Principles
in the investment community and to drive more responsible business practices in line with
the Guiding Principles.
46.
The promotion of human rights through public procurement, in line with target 12.7
of the Sustainable Development Goals, was discussed. Public procurement was seen as
important for upholding respect for human rights in the business sector. Challenges
remained, however, including: insufficient political commitment by Governments and
policymakers, a lack of understanding by procurers, a lack of policy coherence, the absence
of a gender-sensitive approach in most countries, a lack of peer-learning platforms and the
continuing presence of corruption in public procurement.
47.
In another session, participants addressed the role of State-owned enterprises, which
were acknowledged as an enduring and significant feature of the global economy that could
have major environmental, social and human rights impacts. It was noted that, while some
State-owned enterprises were leaders in terms of responsible business conduct and human
rights, others lagged behind and were involved in business-related human rights abuses.
16
10
See www.ohchr.org/EN/Issues/Business/Pages/OHCHRaccountabilityandremedyproject.aspx.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents