A/HRC/12/43
page 15
the United Nations. The project provides for technical assistance for the establishment of the
commission, extensive awareness-raising activities, as well as material assistance and in-depth
training for the commission once established. An initial draft law was produced in this context
through a participatory process which was modified upon review by the Council of Ministers in
November 2008.
56. On analysing the degree of conformity of the draft law as adopted by the Council of
Ministers with the principles relating to the status of national institutions (the Paris Principles),
OHCHR found that it failed to conform in important ways with respect to the functions and
powers of the commission and the minimum qualifications, composition and appointment
process of commissioners. At the time of writing, the Government had indicated that the draft
law would be reconsidered by the Council of Ministers.
B. The transitional justice mechanisms
57. The Arusha Agreement foresaw the establishment of three transitional justice mechanisms,
namely an international commission of judicial inquiry, a national truth and reconciliation
commission (TRC), and an international criminal tribunal. The first two mechanisms were aimed
at shedding light on the cycles of violence suffered by Burundi since its independence in 1962,
characterized by divisions among the three ethnic components of Burundian society: the Hutu,
the Tutsi and the Batwa. It was envisaged that the tribunal would judge and punish those found
guilty of crimes of genocide, war crimes, and crimes against humanity.
58. In conformity with Security Council resolution 1606 (2005), negotiations were initiated
with the Government of Burundi to proceed with the establishment of the transitional justice
mechanisms. Two rounds of consultations were held, in 2006 and 2007, advancing discussions
on the establishment of a TRC and judicial remedies, the latter taking the form of a proposal for
a special tribunal as the negotiations proceeded. The imperative of consulting the Burundian
people was also agreed upon so that their views would be reflected in the establishment of the
mechanisms. However, no conclusions were reached on the questions of amnesty, the
independence of the prosecutor and the relationship between the TRC and the special tribunal.
The question of amnesty was discussed extensively during the May 2007 visit of the then
United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, Louise Arbour, and was settled in
Burundian law in the revised Criminal Code of 2009, which explicitly precludes amnesties for
the crime of genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes.15
59. A second matter where progress was made during the visit of the former High
Commissioner concerned the practical arrangements for the organization of the national
consultations. To this end, the former High Commissioner and the President agreed to establish a
tripartite steering committee, composed of representatives of the Government, the
United Nations, and civil society. The Tripartite Committee for National Consultations on
Transitional Justice (TSC) was established in November 2007 through the signing of the
Framework Agreement by the First Vice-President of the Republic and the Executive
Representative of the Secretary-General for Burundi. The TSC is now supported by its own
15
Criminal Code 2009, article 171, paragraph 2.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents