A/HRC/8/52
page 141
Papua and Poso. It indicated that the role of the Attorney General’s Office in ensuring impunity
remains a key obstacle in the country and regretted that the universal periodic review failed to
identify the problem and make recommendations in this regard.
371. In a joint statement, the World Organization against Torture and Human Rights First noted
that the report of the Working Group focuses on plans and institutions, but does not fully address
their impact. Questions, responses and recommendations failed to note that the effectiveness of
the National Human Rights Commission has been severely limited in recent years, due in part to
an impasse with the military and Parliament. The organization further recommended that
Indonesia take concrete measures to end impunity, such as legislative and executive measures to
resolve the impasse at the National Human Rights Commission; to assign individual
responsibility for crimes against humanity in Timor-Leste; to reform the Human Rights Court
system to ensure prosecution of serious past and present human rights violations; and to revise
the criminal code to include a clear definition of torture and appropriate penalties.
372. Amnesty International welcomed the call made to the Government during the review to
support and protect human rights defenders in Indonesia. It noted that human rights defenders in
the province of Papua operate in a climate of fear and that their activities are restricted by a
heavy presence of security personnel. It called on the Government to guarantee the rights to
freedom of expression and assembly in Papua and Maluku provinces, and to ensure that the
police and the military are aware of the legitimate role of human rights defenders and their
responsibility to protect them. Amnesty International welcomed Indonesia’s commitment
reaffirmed during the review to combat impunity, however it noted that despite the creation
in 2000 of a human rights court to deal with gross human rights violations, the Government has
failed to bring to justice those responsible for such violations.
373. On behalf of the Asian Forum for Human Rights and Developments (Forum-Asia) and the
Indonesian NGO coalition that submitted reports and contributed to the universal periodic review
process, Forum-Asia expressed their appreciation to all members and observers of the Working
Group that raised critical comments reflecting the most pressing human rights issues in
Indonesia. On combating extreme poverty, Forum-Asia noted that the number of Indonesians
living in extreme poverty has increased significantly in the last few years despite the
implementation of recent policies. On the protection of minorities, Forum-Asia indicated that the
Coordinating Body to Monitor Beliefs within Society has become a serious threat to the
protection of religious minority rights including Ahmadiyah, as it has been accompanied by a
wave of violent acts by religious extremist groups who have increased attacks against religious
minorities and supporters of religious pluralism over the last eight months. Forum-Asia further
noted that it deeply regretted the recent decision of the Indonesian Government to partially ban
Ahmadiyah activities, as this might become the justification for the religious extremist group to
attack the Ahmadiyah followers and pro-pluralism group. Finally Forum-Asia encouraged the
Council and its members to closely monitor the progress made in implementing the
recommendations, and to develop a concrete and measurable follow-up mechanism to the review
process.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents