A/HRC/34/70
an alternative to mandatory military service. Prime Minister Netanyahu promised to remove
such organizations from the eligibility list following the criticism by B’Tselem of the
country’s settlement policy at the United Nations in October. Gisha, which would be
adversely impacted by the proposed legislation, stated that the bill “is about labelling and
excluding — as a first step towards delegitimizing — civil society organizations. To put it
more bluntly — this is political persecution”.78
60.
In early March 2017, the Knesset enacted legislation that would deny an entry visa
or residency permit to any non-citizen if that person had worked for an organization that
had issued a public call to boycott the State of Israel or had agreed to participate in such a
boycott. That would include anyone who focused their call for a boycott only on the Israeli
settlements in the Occupied Palestinian Territory. The legislation appears to be the
formalization of an earlier policy announced in August 2016 by the Minister of Public
Security to deport international human rights defenders who support the Boycott,
Divestment, Sanctions movement and to prevent others from entering the country. In
December 2016, Isabel Apawo Phiri, a Malawian citizen who serves as Associate General
Secretary of the World Council of Churches, was denied entry and then deported after
arriving at Ben Gurion International Airport. The Israeli authorities asserted that the denial
of entry was due to the alleged support of her organization for and involvement with the
Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions movement.79 Adalah, an Israeli human rights organization,
criticized the legislation, stating: “Freedom of expression is not just the right to express
oneself, but also the right to be exposed to perspectives … considered outrageous and
infuriating by the majority of [Jewish] Israelis.”80
61.
Palestinian human rights organizations have stated that the Knesset statutes and
proposed bills adversely affect them as well. Palestinian human rights defenders working in
occupied East Jerusalem invariably possess an Israeli residency permit, which they fear
may be revoked by the Ministry of the Interior on the grounds that they have breached their
loyalty to the State of Israel by advocating human rights issues, supporting boycotts or
encouraging the acknowledgment of the Palestinian exodus between 1947 and 1949 (the
Nakba). Palestinian human rights organizations also state that these legislative offences
intensify the atmosphere of fear and repression for human rights defenders. The impact is
also being felt by Palestinian human rights defenders living in Israel on residency permits,
such as Omar Barghouti, a co-founder of the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions movement.
Restrictions on his international travel were temporarily imposed in April 2016, just after
the Intelligence and Transportation Minister had called for the “targeted civil elimination”
of the leaders of the movement with the help of Israeli intelligence. 81
C.
Conclusions
62.
The 50-year occupation of the Palestinian territories, which becomes more
pervasive by the day with no end even remotely in sight, has been profoundly
corrosive of human rights and democratic values. How could it be otherwise? To
perpetuate an alien rule over almost 5 million people, against their fervent wishes,
inevitably requires the repression of rights, erosion of the rule of law, the abrogation
of international commitments, the imposition of deeply discriminatory practices, the
hollowing-out of well-accepted standards of military behaviour, subjugation of the
humanity of the “other”, denial of trends that are plainly evident, the embrace of
illiberal politics and — the focus of the present report — the scorning of those civil
78
79
80
81
Gisha, “The battle is not for national service spots, it is for the very foundation of democracy in
Israel”, 10 November 2016.
Ilan Lior, “In first, Israel denies entry to religious official citing support of BDS movement”,
Haaretz, 6 December 2016.
See www.adalah.org/en/content/view/9043.
See communication sent to Special Rapporteurs by 12 Palestinian human rights organizations,
“Urgent appeal concerning human rights defenders working on OPT and Israel,” 13 June 2016,
available from alhaq.org/images/stories/PDF/2012/Letter_on_HRDs_pdf.pdf; and Amnesty
International, “Israeli government must cease intimidation”.
17
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents