A/HRC/41/35/Add.1
C.
Safety of journalists
32.
The Special Rapporteurs agree that the changes in the country’s political context in
2017 have had a positive impact on the state of freedom of expression, with a decrease in
attacks on journalists in 2018. Nevertheless, they were informed that the right to freedom of
expression continued to be at risk, with civil society organizations reporting cases involving
physical assaults against journalists and other people who exercise freedom of expression
on a regular basis, and attacks on digital rights. While acknowledging the Government’s
efforts to address this climate of violence against journalists, previously characterized by
stigmatizing and denigrating speech, the Special Rapporteurs are concerned about the
possibility that cases and acts of violence against journalists remain unpunished, thereby
contributing to the occurrence of new cases.
33.
The Special Rapporteurs also note that the kidnapping and subsequent murder of the
journalist Javier Ortega Reyes, the press photographer Paúl Rivas Bravo and their driver,
Efraín Segarra Abril, in 2018 was the most serious attack on the Ecuadorian media by an
organized criminal group. In addition to issuing precautionary measures, the InterAmerican Commission on Human Rights set up a special follow-up team at the request of
Ecuador, outlining the mandate of the team in its resolution 54/2018 of 17 July 2018. The
team was officially installed on 25 July 2018, and has been in operation ever since. The
Special Rapporteurs condemn this atrocious crime and express their solidarity with the
families of the men who were murdered.
34.
The Special Rapporteurs note that the attack revealed protection deficiencies in
Ecuador, which reportedly has almost no measures or protocols in place to ensure the safety
of journalists and media workers. The case also drew public attention to shortcomings in
access to public information, especially by families, during crisis situations such as
kidnappings or disappearances. In view of this situation, the Special Rapporteurs urge the
Government to take significant steps to strengthen press operations and security in Ecuador,
especially in high-risk areas such as the border with Colombia, and to implement effective
protection mechanisms. The Government should help establish risk maps and provide
accurate information regarding potential dangers journalists may face. It should also collect
and publish data regarding incidents of violence against journalists and media workers.
35.
The Special Rapporteurs stress the importance of, and view positively, the creation
of an inter-institutional committee for the protection of journalists and media workers,
announced by the Secretary for Communication and established on 29 April 2019.
According to reports, the committee will coordinate the efforts of various institutions and
civil society to provide protection for journalists in situations of risk and to establish a
violence-prevention policy. The Special Rapporteurs remind the State that this committee
should include stakeholders such as journalists, civil society organizations, representatives
of the media and relatives of victims. Its risk assessment methodologies should include a
differentiated approach that takes account of the specific risks faced by certain groups of
journalists, including women journalists and community and indigenous media workers.
36.
In addition, the Special Rapporteurs recommend that the Government ensure that all
staff members of every department involved in the committee be trained on how to meet
their obligations to protect journalists and media workers, and that they fully understand the
importance of the role of journalists in a democratic society. The Government must also
provide sufficient resources for the initiative to ensure effective coordination among all the
authorities and to enable it to operate sustainably in the different regions of the country. It is
also essential to strengthen coordination with the Office of the Prosecutor General so that it
can fulfil its responsibility to identify and investigate the risks faced by journalists who are
attacked and threatened. The Government must be firm in its condemnation of threats and
violence against journalists, and must investigate such incidents fully, effectively and
impartially.
37.
In addition to the reports of physical attacks, the Special Rapporteurs learned during
their visits of reports of journalists and media outlets being hacked. Digital safety and
security were often sabotaged by the previous Government, which carried out cyberattacks
on journalists. Many journalists had their content taken down from social media and other
8
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents