A/HRC/7/26
Page 17
VII. FIELD VISITS
A. Visit to Baidoa
68.
The independent expert’s mission to Somalia included a planned and authorized visit to
Baidoa on 17 September 2007 in order to meet with various officials of the TFIs. Unfortunately,
that morning he was prevented from disembarking the plane on arrival in Baidoa and was
obliged to return to Nairobi. Following this incident, he received numerous apologies from
various members of the TFG and an undertaking that the incident would be investigated. While
appreciating all the apologies and explanations received after this incident, the experience starkly
highlighted for the independent expert the arbitrariness of decision-making by authorities and the
deficiencies in institutional structures in Somalia.
B. Visit to Mogadishu
69.
On 20 September 2007, the independent expert met with President Abdullahi Yusuf. The
President began by offering renewed apologies over the Baidoa incident stating that the
independent expert was always welcome. The independent expert raised the issue of the negative
environment for journalists and the media to which the President stated that some media
organizations presented legitimate security concerns in that they were “hiding terrorists.”
President Yusuf also noted that human rights reports were often mere allegations by human
rights organizations which very often could not be corroborated or considered credible.
70.
The independent expert also met with the (then) Prime Minister of the TFG, Ali
Mohamed Gedi, in Mogadishu. The latter also apologized for the Baidoa incident and assured
the independent expert that those responsible would be held accountable. The independent expert
then briefed the Prime Minister on his previous reports and presentations to the Human Rights
Council. 3 The independent expert raised several issues arising from his current mission with the
Prime Minister, including reiterating his recommendation that the Somali Government sign and
ratify all key international human rights instruments, as well as his opinion that the establishment
of a national human rights commission would assist in addressing some of the pressing human
rights challenges facing Somalia. He encouraged the TFG to request the assistance of the Human
Rights Adviser deployed to the United Nations Country Team. The Prime Minister stated that the
TFG remained committed to the idea of a national human rights institution and stressed that
international assistance and support would be necessary in order to achieve this goal.
71.
In a meeting with the Chair of the National Governance and Reconciliation Commission,
Ali Mahdi, the independent expert was apprised of the outcomes of the National Reconciliation
Congress. He learned that the Congress will be followed by discussions facilitated by
participants within their communities in a parallel track to the constitution drafting process.
72.
The independent expert also met with 15 members of the Hawiye Elders Council while in
Mogadishu. The Elders expressed dissatisfaction with the presence of Ethiopian military and
argued that their withdrawal presented the starting point for securing stability in Somalia. They
also strongly condemned the fighting and conflicts of the past year, comparing the situation to
3
See A/HRC/5/2, A/HRC/2/CRP.2 and E/CN.4/2005/117.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents