A/HRC/7/26
Page 13
III. GOVERNANCE, RULE OF LAW ISSUES AND IMPUNITY
45.
Lack of governance and rule of law, weak institutions and impunity are not in and of
themselves human rights issues. Rather, they are the circumstances and context which create and
allow for human rights infringements and violations, enable them to continue unabated or
prevent their remedy or redress. Principles of good governance and the rule of law are built on
human rights standards and norms such as due process, gender equality, participation and nondiscrimination.
46.
It has too long been the case in Somalia that a weakly functioning central Government
has resulted in an absence of order, security, the rule of law and justice. There is no central
trained police service and there is often no independent and professional judiciary, which creates
a climate of utter impunity. The judiciary and police or security services do not function and
customary (xeer), Islamic law (sharia) and various national legal standards are applied arbitrarily
in the absence of a national legal framework. Decisions are often taken by officials without
regard to transparency, fairness and accountability.
47.
On the second day of his mission on 18 September, the independent expert experienced
first-hand arbitrary treatment when he was prevented from disembarking at the Baidoa airport
despite having received prior authorization. He was obliged to return to Nairobi, where he was
met with official apologies from the TFG and the promise of an investigation into the matter.
Also, while on mission, the independent expert learned that the President of the Supreme Court,
Yusuf Ali Harun and another judge of the Supreme Court had been arrested and that the
Attorney-General, Abdullahi Dahir and his deputy had been dismissed. As at the writing of this
report, the President of Supreme Court and his associate were still awaiting trial. The
independent expert condemns these decisions taken without regard to rules and procedures and
which clearly violate the doctrines of the separation of powers and the independence of the
judiciary.
48.
The independent expert contends that the most pressing governance areas in need of
reform and strengthening include the executive office or cabinet, ministry of the attorney-general
and the judicial branch, and ministries such as interior and those responsible for the security
sector.
49.
During the mission, the independent expert was updated on rule of law and security
issues by colleagues of the Rule of Law and Security Program of the United Nations
Development Programme (UNDP). The independent expert learned that in Baidoa there is a
semblance of a law system, in which arrests and cases were being channelled through. It was
also noted that in Mogadishu, cases were being considered in a new system applying a mixture
of customary and civil law. Customary law was also slowly being introduced into the penal code
in some courts in south and central Somalia, allowing for the enforcement of customary laws.
Some local communities were also beginning to vet nominees to the judiciary in south and
central Somalia.
50.
The independent expert was also briefed about the introduction of a civilian advisory
committee or monitoring mechanism for policing in Mogadishu. It was stated that 8 of 16 police
stations were currently being monitored in order to avoid the transfer of prisoners from
monitored to unmonitored prisons. In addition, monitoring ensured that persons were not
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents