A/HRC/29/39
(b)
To develop credible and workable recommendations and guidance for States
in relation to each of the six project components (see sect. II.A) to enable a stronger and
more consistent implementation of the Guiding Principles, particularly in so far as business
involvement in severe human rights abuses is concerned.
9.
The decision to focus on cases of severe abuse in the first instance has been taken
for strategic, substantive and methodological reasons. First, this prioritization is justified by
the severity of impacts for victims. Second, as noted above, business involvement in gross
human rights abuses poses a particular set of challenges in respect of access to remedy.
Third, the steps already taken by many States to ensure that international crimes are
punishable at the domestic level make it likely that focusing on the severest forms of human
rights abuse will be the most useful and revealing starting point for close comparative
analysis. However, this in no way implies that severe business-related human rights abuses
should be the sole focus of States’ regulatory action. On the contrary, mindful that the
Guiding Principles address the full range of business-related human rights impacts, and that
in many contexts it is impossible or undesirable to carve out specialist regimes for a
particular class of human rights abuses, OHCHR will be examining the outcomes of the
accountability and remedy project for lessons of relevance for access to remedy not only in
the severest cases.
10.
The accountability and remedy project will focus on judicial mechanisms for gaining
access to remedy. This is not to diminish the importance of non-judicial mechanisms,
which, as noted in Guiding Principle 27, are part of a comprehensive State-based system for
the remedy of business-related human rights abuse. However, given the project’s focus on
the severest cases, which by their very nature may raise issues of possible criminal
behaviour, it is appropriate to focus on domestic mechanisms responsible for enforcing
criminal law. Data on the use of non-judicial mechanisms will be collected (see sect. II.B),
as OHCHR recognizes the role that such mechanisms can play in reducing the costs of
dispute resolution and in creating more opportunities for victims to access effective
remedies. In order for States to effectively hold businesses to account and to ensure access
to remedy in the severest cases, however, non-judicial mechanisms must be backed up by
effective judicial mechanisms.
11.
Finally, although the project focuses on access to remedy issues, there is a need for
both States and businesses to make concerted and increased efforts to develop better
preventive practices and policies with respect to business-related human rights abuses.
While the development of preventive practices and policies are beyond the scope of the
project, the methodology recognizes the relationships that can exist between the preventive
efforts of a business enterprise and its legal risks and culpability. As part of the project,
input will be gathered from many different jurisdictions on issues such as the bearing that
human rights due diligence may have on legal liability and sanctioning, in order to better
explore the linkages that exist between prevention and legal liability. This will be done to
ensure that the practical recommendations arising from the project address, to the extent
possible, the need for prevention as well as remedy.
12.
The mandate of the accountability and remedy project is separate from, but
potentially complementary to, the decision made by the Human Rights Council in its
resolution 26/9 to establish an open-ended intergovernmental working group on human
rights and transnational corporations and other business enterprises to elaborate an
international legally binding instrument. The project is not linked to the negotiations on that
instrument. However, if the intergovernmental working group so decides, it could draw
upon material emerging from the project in its discussions.
5
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents