A/HRC/13/33
IV.
Addressing the specific needs of smallholders
A.
The challenges
28.
Smallholders in developing countries, cultivating small plots of land often with little
or no public support, are the single most important group of those who are food insecure in
the world today. To the extent that they do not market their produce themselves, and lack
storage and processing facilities, smallholders often face a very limited number of buyers.
For smallholders, the key factor is the price they receive for their crops. In the next
paragraphs the Special Rapporteur explores the initiatives States could take in order to
protect the right to food of smallholders, and the measures which could be taken by the
agribusiness companies to respect the right to food in their relationships with smallholders.
The overall objective is to ensure that smallholders capture a fair proportion of the value of
their products, despite the very unequal bargaining position in which they find themselves
at the moment vis-à-vis commodity buyers.
B.
The role of States in protecting the right to food
29.
By encouraging the diversification of channels of trading and distribution and by
ensuring the viability of wholesale and local markets, States create a wider range of options
for smallholders, thus improving their bargaining position in the food chain. In particular, it
is vital that farmers are not forced to join the agro-export networks, and that they are
sufficiently supported if they opt, instead, for the production of food crops for local
consumption. This has not always been the case in the past; since farmers supplying the
international markets reaped a disproportionate share of public support (in access to credit,
to technologies, or to infrastructure), the choice for smallholders was often between
switching to cash crops for exports, something only a minority achieved, or living off
subsistence agriculture. A number of countries are now seeking to put an end to this
imbalance, and this is to be welcomed. But more precise measures could also be taken.
1.
Creating a wider range of options for smallholders: cooperatives, marketing boards,
and public procurement
30.
States have at their disposal a number of tools in order to strengthen the position of
smallholders and allow them to reap a larger proportion of the value in their transactions
with buyers. The provision of information about prices and the improvement of
communication infrastructures are essential, allowing producers to improve their bargaining
position vis-à-vis buyers and to transport their crops more easily to the markets, where they
can obtain better prices from other buyers. In this section three other instruments are
examined — farmers’ cooperatives, marketing arrangements, and public procurement —
that States could explore in order to address the specific needs of smallholders.
31.
States could support the establishment of farmers’ cooperatives and other producer
organizations. When they were controlled by governments in the past, cooperatives
sometimes captured value instead of ensuring fair revenues for farmers, and they were seen
as inefficient. In many countries, parastatal cooperatives were dismantled during the 1980s.
This led to the emergence of a large number of producer organizations, established on
their own initiative.32 For small producers, grouping together presents a number of
32
GE.09-17776
For instance, between 1982 and 2002 the percentage of villages with producer organizations rose
from 8 per cent to 65 per cent in Senegal and from 21 per cent to 91 per cent in Burkina Faso. It is
estimated that 250 million farmers in developing countries belong to one association. See World
11
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents