A/HRC/9/12
page 10
women having their hijab, or headscarf, forcibly removed in public places. The Special
Rapporteur also drew attention to the increasing number of cases of physical and verbal
aggression directed at Muslims. He pointed out that airports remain a focus for individual acts of
Islamophobia by passengers and sometimes by crew members, as well as for institutional
discrimination on the part of security and immigration officials.
25. The Special Rapporteur also noted with disquiet the collective manifestations of
discrimination and intolerance towards Islam, particularly as regards its outward signs. These
manifestations are accompanied by an intolerant secularist rhetoric leading to still greater
discrimination against Muslims. This powerful trend is particularly marked in relation to the
construction of mosques: systematic opposition to the building of mosques and minarets is the
most symbolic expression of Islamophobia in terms of the denial of religious freedom in two of
its most basic aspects - the visibility of religious practice and the availability of a place of
worship. A recent example is the demolition in May 2008 of a mosque in the town of Verona
(Italy) following a systematic campaign by a number of leaders of the Northern league, a major
political component of the current coalition Government in Italy. The projected referendum on
the banning of minarets by a party that is a long-time member of the Government coalition in
Switzerland is part of the same current of intolerance and xenophobia. Legal harassment against
the construction of mosques or minarets illustrates the crucial nature of this question in the
programme of many political parties, particularly those of nationalist and extreme-right
persuasion.
26. Throughout his term of office, the Special Rapporteur has emphasized that the place to be
accorded to Islam represents a key issue in the construction of the new European identity, as
illustrated during the preparation of the draft European Constitution by the proposal - ultimately
rejected - that it should include an explicit reference to Europe’s Christian roots. A similar line of
thought lies behind the arguments of those opposed to Turkey’s membership of the European
Union, with periodic contributions from certain members of Europe’s political and intellectual
elites. The Special Rapporteur notes in this connection that the question that is overlooked in the
debate on the construction of Europe, largely focused on its political and economic dimensions,
is that of the reconstruction of a multicultural identity in the new Europe.
27. The central issues at stake in the manifestations and expressions of Islamophobia are
freedom of religious belief and incitement to racial and religious hatred. In its most sophisticated
expressions, particularly its ideological justification and theoretical formulation, Islamophobia
links these two issues. The challenge to the principle of freedom of religious belief as it relates to
Islam, particularly its outward signs and expression, is reflected in a deliberate strategy of
incitement to racial and religious hatred. Its legitimization is centred on the “defence” of two
particularly sensitive topics - national identity and security. Its rhetorical concepts serve as the
basis for intellectual constructions and are exploited in political platforms and nurture media
images: suspicion of the believer as backward-looking, irrational and non-modern; association of
Islam with violence and terrorism, particularly since 11 September 2001; identification of
multiculturalism and immigration as threats to national, ethnic, cultural and religious identity. Its
psychological springs are fear, immurement and rejection. The two key issues ultimately at stake
here relate to the fundamental freedoms defined and elaborated in the International Covenant on
Civil and Political Rights, in particular articles 18, 19 and 20.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents