A/HRC/39/34
While too small a sample size might not be statistically significant, not capturing such
diversity would likely mean that certain groups remained invisible and excluded.
27.
Furthermore, several experts emphasized that the majority of women, girls and
gender non-conforming persons belonging to marginalized groups were still made invisible
and excluded in the implementation of the 2030 Agenda. Elements that hindered the
participation of those women and girls and data collection on them included lack of
citizenship; being in detention (including in penitentiary facilities, immigration centres,
residential institutions and hospitals); being criminalized (for example, sex workers, drug
users, undocumented migrants or lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex persons);
barriers in relation to infrastructure, transport, communication or information; and harmful
stereotypes and discrimination. It was suggested that States might need to engage
proactively with women and girls belonging to marginalized groups, as they might lack
sufficient resources and representation in general processes of the implementation of the
2030 Agenda.
28.
The experts pointed out that marginalized groups often had to insist on and fight for
their recognition. Civil society organizations and organizations representing marginalized
groups had a vital role to play in demanding such recognition. At the same time, views and
positions on certain issues might be divided among organizations representing a particular
group (such as organizations of persons with disabilities or representatives of indigenous
peoples) and among organizations working on different issues (for example, women’s
rights, children’s rights and the rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex
persons). Such divisions could undermine their collective mobilization. More dialogue
might be needed among organizations representing marginalized groups themselves and
more cooperation and collaboration among human rights organizations, women’s
organizations and organizations representing marginalized groups would be beneficial. In
order to capture the diversity of various groups of women and girls, some experts
underscored the need for intercultural and intergenerational dialogue and for the recognition
of diverse world views held by different groups, including the concept of collective rights.
The importance of cultural identity and cultural integrity was also noted.
V. Monitoring progress on gender equality and women’s rights
29.
The discussion on data also covered the issue of how to measure progress made on
gender equality and the realization of women’s rights in the implementation of the 2030
Agenda.
30.
One expert emphasized that indicators identified for monitoring progress in reaching
the Millennium Development Goals and the Sustainable Development Goals focused on
measuring progress in the condition of women and girls, such as their health status, but did
not measure how their social positions had been improved. Unless the social positions of
women and girls were improved, progress made on their condition would not be
sustainable. For example, investing in reproductive health-care service delivery would not
lead to sustainable access to such services by women and girls unless they gained an
autonomous decision-making capacity and control over the social and financial resources to
gain access to such services. As a methodology to measure gender-transformative outcomes
of programmes, Plan International Canada had developed the Women and Girls
Empowerment Index. 11 It measured changes directly associated with the root causes of
gender inequality across five domains: roles and responsibilities; resource access and
control; participation and decision-making; social norms; and institutional change. In order
to measure gender transformative changes, changes in attitudes and perceptions concerning
gender relations should be measured not only for women and girls but also for men and
boys.
11
8
See “Plan International Canada’s Architecture for Gender Transformative Programming and
Measurement: A Primer”.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents