A/HRC/2/7
page 21
are no longer habitable due to extensive damage. Of these, 400 people are still residing in
hotels.133 The Government will also compensate those who suffered bodily injury as a result of
the conflict, e.g. due to rocket shrapnel.
94.
In the course of the visit, however, the mission heard persistent complaints that affected
members of the Arab Israeli community were discriminated against and disadvantaged in the
payment of compensation for their damages incurred during the war. The perception among
some of the mission’s interlocutors was that the Tax Authority’s assessors would systematically
underestimate the property damage suffered by them. Challenging the Authority’s assessment
requires means which Arab Israelis often lack and delays the payment process, which many
cannot afford. Similarly, with regard to claims arising from injuries, the mission heard
allegations of health officials unjustly denying claims on the basis that the injury was not proven
to be related to the war. Where an injury requires long-term treatment, including for mental
health patients, the grave effects of such a determination on the access to health care of the
victim and the financial situation of the family are obvious. The mission could neither
investigate individual cases of alleged unjust denial, nor of course the alleged systemic and thus
discriminatory dimension of such denials.
95.
In order to ensure better protection for the civilian population in the future there is a clear
need for the authorities to build, repair and upgrade shelters throughout the country, in particular
in towns and villages with Arab populations. There is also a need to be better prepared to
provide adequate humanitarian assistance in possible future armed conflicts, in particular to the
poor, children, the sick and the elderly.
96.
An official assessment of the environmental damage caused by the conflict in the north
confirms, inter alia, that sewage plants were damaged and, in some cases, effluent had to be
released into the sea and atmosphere (by burning).134 The mission was also informed that
unexploded ordnance remains a problem over a wide area.
97.
While medical services have resumed their activities, there is a need to better prepare and
equip hospitals for possible future attacks (e.g. fully equipped underground facilities). As in
Lebanon, the recent conflict poses a profound and continuing challenge to the mental and
psychosocial well-being of the Israeli population, especially women and children and the elderly,
giving rise to many cases of post-traumatic stress disorder.135 Four weeks after hostilities ended,
an Israeli mental health specialist reported that hospitals were receiving “late reactions” to the
conflict. He estimated that these amounted to “a few hundreds”, but he expected they would
climb to “a few thousands”. In both countries, health professionals emphasized the high level of
stress disorders, observed that it is much too early to assess the full impact of the conflict on
individuals’ mental and psychosocial health, and urged that more resources be made available on
an equitable basis for these extremely important issues.136
VI. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
98.
In addition to human rights law, the principles of humanitarian law are entirely
applicable to this conflict and deviations from these principles cannot be justified on the
basis of the alleged novelty or distinctiveness of this conflict.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents