A/HRC/20/16
and/or to keep them under economic subjugation, sexual exploitation, gender domination
and control.53 In Nepal, particularly in the southern Terai region, elderly women, widows,
destitute women and women of low caste are often targeted and deprived of their property
rights or victimized to settle a personal vendetta.54
40.
In Papua New Guinea, cases of torture and murder of an estimated 500 women
accused of practising sorcery/witchcraft have been reported. 55 Sorcery allegations against
women have been increasing, in particular in the Highlands region.56 Suspected witches
have been thrown from cliffs, tortured, dragged behind cars, burned or buried alive. Victims
of such attacks and killings are mainly widows or other vulnerable elderly women who do
not have children or relatives to protect them, women born out of wedlock or women who
do not have any standing in the family. 57 According to police reports, women are six times
more likely than men to be accused of sorcery.58
41.
Those who torture or kill are almost exclusively men, and are often related socially
or biologically to the victim. 59 Some accusations of sorcery are economically motivated, for
the purpose of taking over land or possessions of those accused, or because payments have
been made by third parties to name alleged sorcerers. According to expert reports,
―increasingly, there is a perception that accusations of sorcery are a convenient disguise for
premeditated killings based more on a person‘s dislike for another, jealousy, envy, greed,
rivalry or revenge and targeting women from the tribes or communities‖.60
42.
A study showing sentencing patterns in witchcraft-related cases in Southern Africa
reveals that men accused of killings of women were sentenced to shorter periods of time,
and often the charges were reduced to minor crimes. Overall, sentences were lenient when
the perpetrator was the husband or a male relative of the woman killed. In Zambia, for
instance, the average sentence was one to two years for charges of premeditated homicide
of women.61
Killings of women and girls in the name of “honour”
3.
43.
As noted by the Secretary-General, certain cultural norms and beliefs are the causal
factors of harmful practices resulting in violence against women, such as crimes committed
in the name of ―honour‖.62 Honour killings have been characterized as being among the
most severe manifestations of harmful practices. 63 Murder to cleanse family honour is
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
A/HRC/11/6/Add.1, 2009, at para. 228. See also Saravanan, S., Violence against women in India: A
literature review (New Delhi, Institute of Social Studies Trust, 2000); Chen, M. A., ―Widowhood and
aging in India‖, United Nations Research Institute for Social Development case study available at:
http://www.unrisd.org/unrisd/website/projects.nsf/(httpAuxPages)/25DCC0F9F3E206C3C1256BB20
0552FC6?OpenDocument&category=Case+Studies.
Jill Schnoebelen, ―Witchcraft allegations, refugee protection and human rights: a review of the
evidence‖, New Issues in Refugee Research, Research Paper No. 169, Policy Development and
Evaluation Service, 2009, p. 11.
Supra Note 45 at p. 49
The broad majority of the population in the highlands believes in extra-natural explanations to life
misfortunes. When a death, sickness or an accident occurs, it is common to explain it as having been
caused by the use of sorcery.
Sorcery, Witchcraft and Christianity in Melanesia by Franco Zocca and Jack Urame, Melenesian
Institute 2008.
See also Amnesty International 2009 and The National, June 19, 2003, p. 6.
Supra Note 46.
Ibid., p. 3.
Rude, D. and M. Kazunga. (1995) ―Report on the femicide research‖. Report by country. Zambia.
Women in Law and Development in Africa.
Supra Note 6, at para. 78.
Ibid., at para. 123.
11
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents