A/HRC/38/50
with a peak of 3,183 in September. Close to 7 per cent of all Eritrean applicants were
unaccompanied children, with Eritreans representing the third largest citizenship in this
category of vulnerable applicants.16
95.
The Special Rapporteur has learned that the Eritrean authorities do not issue exit visas
to children over 5 years old, which then forces families to take alternative measures to move
children across borders. This is an unfortunate measure which further fuels the irregular
movement of children.
96.
During the period January–April 2018, Eritreans constituted the fifth most common
nationality of Mediterranean Sea arrivals, with 1,810 arrivals. 17 In Italy, Eritreans were the
primary nationality that arrived by sea in March 2018, comprising 23 per cent of the overall
arrival numbers.18
97.
In 2017 over 30,000 refugee and migrant children arrived in Europe via the three
Mediterranean routes, over 17,000 of them unaccompanied, coming mostly from four
African countries, including Eritrea. As children travelled to Europe, many experienced
physical violence and kidnapping for ransom or detention by armed groups and other
dangers.19
98.
Throughout her tenure, the Special Rapporteur has raised concerns regarding the
protection of Eritrean refugees and has continued to follow developments in a number of host
countries during the reporting period.
99.
In Switzerland, Eritreans continue to constitute the biggest group of asylum seekers
and their situation has received considerable public attention. Following its decision of
February 2017, the Swiss Federal Administrative Court adopted a second decision in August
2017, holding that Eritreans who had served in the Eritrean national service would not
necessarily face the risk of being recalled back into service or punished if they returned.
100. In early 2018, the Swiss State Secretariat for Migration decided to reassess the
temporary residence of 3,000 Eritreans with the ultimate goal of return in the absence of a
readmission agreement. The Special Rapporteur is fully aware of the considerable domestic
pressure to curb the large number of Eritreans seeking asylum in Switzerland. However, these
people, including many unaccompanied children, are fleeing from a dire human rights
situation and a policy change regarding their access to protection would be difficult to justify
without any significant changes on the ground.
101. In September 2017, the United States Department of Homeland Security announced
measures to expedite the deportation of Eritreans back to Eritrea. In a joint urgent appeal to
the Government of the United States in December 2017, Human Rights Council special
procedure mandate holders expressed serious concern over the risk of a return to Eritrea of
about 700 Eritrean nationals, in potential violation of the non-refoulement principle.20
Mandate holders argued that, given the situation in Eritrea, those forcibly returned were at
high risk of being arrested, detained and subjected to ill-treatment and torture. If forcibly
returned, Eritreans considered by the Government as having left the country illegally would
face a risk of prolonged detention without access to legal representation and family members.
The Special Rapporteur appreciates the substantive reply from the Government of the United
States dated March 2018, as detailed in the communications report.
102. In a joint communication to the Government of Israel dated 19 February 2018,
mandate holders raised concerns about the risk of refoulement of Eritrean nationals residing
in Israel through forced relocation to third countries on the African continent, possibly not
offering effective protection to those affected.21
103. Mandate holders also expressed concern about the extremely low recognition rate of
asylum applications concerning Eritrean nationals by Israel, and the lack of recognition of
16
17
18
19
20
21
See European Asylum Support Office, “Latest Asylum Trends – Overview 2017”, 1 February 2018.
See UNHCR, Operational Portal: Refugee Situations, “Mediterranean situation”.
See UNHCR, ��Europe Monthly Report” newsletter, 20 April 2018, p. 1.
See UNHCR, Desperate Journeys, January 2017–March 2018, p. 15.
See communication dated 21 December 2017 and reply by the United States of 7 March 2018,
available from https://spcommreports.ohchr.org/LatestReports/CommunicationSent.
Available from https://spcommreports.ohchr.org/LatestReports/CommunicationSent.
15
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents