A/HRC/35/15
detention centres. He added that the information shared by the panellists was not new to
anyone, as lack of information or evidence was not a problem. He highlighted that since the
Nuremberg trials, there had not been a context with such a large amount of evidence and
witnesses. The problem was the lack of political will to stop the carnage.
35.
Mr. Darwish added that detentions in the Syrian Arab Republic, such as his, that of
his wife, parents and father-in-law, occurred with some legal cover provided either by
government courts or by sharia courts. Field military courts had issued thousands of death
sentences without respecting due process. The recently published report by Amnesty
International was only part of a much graver reality. Extermination, a term used by the
Commission of Inquiry, was ongoing. Those atrocities, which had been committed for six
years, were continuing as the Human Rights Council was in session. Civilians, including
women and children, who had committed no crime were dying under torture.
36.
The answer to the frequent questions on how extremism had come about, on why
young people were joining criminal gangs and on the activities of terrorists groups lay in
Syrian detention centres and prisons. The root causes of terrorism needed to be looked into
in order for terrorism to be defeated.
37.
The dream of many Syrians was for the war to come to an end, but they wondered
how peace and a political solution could be achieved while hundreds of thousands of
Syrians were detained or missing; how there could be real peace without accountability for
the crimes committed. Referring to the political negotiations, Mr. Darwish warned that the
decision to raise the issue of detainees during the talks in Astana instead of in Geneva had
sent a negative signal, as the issue became limited to an exchange of prisoners between
warlords. None of the warring parties was concerned with many of the categories of
persons detained, including human rights defenders. They mostly cared about the interests
of combatants, not about artists, lawyers or activists.
38.
Mr. Darwish ended by expressing the hope that the children of his torturers would
live in peace, just as he hoped his own children would. He added that, in order to avoid
vengeful acts, a genuine transitional justice process was required. Without it, the ground
would be laid for a civil war that would erase what was left of the Syrian Arab Republic
and its people. Without accountability, the international community would send a wrong
signal to criminals throughout the world, giving them the green light to act freely and
continue to commit war crimes and crimes against humanity.
39.
Syrians paid the highest price for the presence of takfiri and extremist groups such
as ISIL and Jabhat al-Nusrah and therefore had the biggest interest in eradicating extremism
and terrorism. Mr. Darwish warned that the mistakes made in Iraq were being replicated.
The situation in the Syrian Arab Republic and the entire Middle East required a
comprehensive solution based on justice and democratic change as the way to guarantee
sustainable peace and eradicate terrorism.
IV. Summary of the discussion
40.
During the interactive phase of the panel discussion, the following delegations spoke
(in order of intervention): the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland (on
behalf of France, Germany, Italy, Jordan, Kuwait, Morocco, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Turkey
and the United States of America), Norway (on behalf of the Nordic countries), Bahrain (on
behalf of the Gulf Cooperation Council), the European Union, Spain, the United Kingdom,
Australia, New Zealand, Uruguay, Germany, Israel, Belgium, Qatar, Slovenia,
Liechtenstein, the Islamic Republic of Iran, the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela, France,
the Plurinational State of Bolivia, the Maldives, the Netherlands, the United States, the
Russian Federation, Switzerland, Italy, Portugal and Iraq.
41.
The following NGOs contributed to the discussion: the Cairo Institute for Human
Rights Studies, the Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom, Human Rights
Watch, the World Council of Arameans (Syriacs), Africa Culture Internationale and the
International Organization for the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination.
8
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents