A/HRC/19/2
562. The International Movement against All Forms of Discrimination and Racism, on
behalf of Pavee Point, stated that Ireland continued to ignore the opinions and
recommendations of a range of eminent international and regional human rights bodies that
had taken the position that the Traveller community met all the legal criteria to be
recognized as an ethnic minority. A report released in 2010 had revealed that Traveller
mortality was higher than that of the general population. It urged Ireland to engage with
Traveller organizations to formulate a response to the issues raised in the said report.
563. The International Federation for Human Rights Leagues welcomed Ireland’s
acceptance of 91 recommendations. It remained concerned about the declaration of partial
acceptance of 17 recommendations, where it was not clear in what precise manner each
recommendation has been accepted. It urged Ireland to ratify all core United Nations
human rights instruments, especially those with monitoring mechanisms, such as the
Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and the Optional Protocol to the
Convention against Torture, and called on Ireland to set out a clear timetable in this regard.
It remained concerned about the rejection of recommendations regarding the
implementation of the judgement of the European Court of Human Rights on access to
abortion, putting an end to ongoing religious discrimination in access to schools and
recognizing Travellers as an official ethnic minority group.
564. Amnesty International urged Ireland to ratify, without further delay, the
International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance,
which had been signed almost five years earlier. Ireland must recognize in law the rights to
health and housing. It urged consideration of these rights at the upcoming review of
Ireland’s Constitution. It also urged Ireland to sign and ratify the Council of Europe
Convention on Violence against Women and Domestic Violence without delay. It
encouraged Ireland to set time frames, to establish a monitoring mechanism for the
implementation of accepted recommendations, and to undertake to provide a midterm
report.
565. Age Action Ireland, a member of the HelpAge International network, together with
the coalition partners (Disability Federation Ireland, the MakeRoom Campaign Alliance,
Mental Health Reform and the Women’s Human Rights Alliance) welcomed the spirit in
which the universal periodic review process of Ireland had been conducted. It commended
Ireland for committing to sign the Optional Protocol to the International Convention on
Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. It also welcomed the partial acceptance of the
recommendation to incorporate into the law the rights to health and housing, and to bring
legislation into line with the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. It hoped
that civil society and the Government could work together, including in the preparation of
the interim report.
566. The society for the Protection of Unborn Children stated that it was the will of the
Irish people that the right to life of unborn babies be protected from the very beginning.
During the universal periodic review, many States had called for Ireland to introduce
abortion. It expressed appreciation for the Irish delegation’s rejection of these calls. Ireland
had an excellent record in protecting the lives of both mothers and babies. Life-saving
medical interventions for pregnant women had always been available. While some children
may not survive those interventions, their deaths were an undesired consequence of the
treatment of the mother’s condition rather than the intended result of the doctor’s actions.
Such interventions should not be confused with abortion procedures.
567. The European Disability Forum, on behalf of the Equality and Rights Alliance
(Ireland), welcomed Ireland’s acceptance of the recommendations on the ratification of the
Convention on the Rights of People with Disabilities, as well as Costa Rica’s
recommendation that measures be taken to allow people with disabilities access to
education, employment, housing, transport and cultural life, and to facilitate their access to
GE.13-14768
217
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents