A/HRC/17/26
aspects, both of which must be addressed if the human rights of all women to live free of
gender-based violence are to be fully realized. Conceptual problems associated with an
incomplete analysis of personhood necessitate the generation of a holistic understanding of
an individual woman’s social location and bodily attributes to better understand the scope
of vulnerability, risk and consequences of violence, whether interpersonal or structural or
both.
C.
The holistic approach to recognizing women’s rights to be free from
discrimination and violence
50.
A holistic approach underscores the interdependence and indivisibility of civil,
political, economic, social and cultural rights; it situates violence against women on a
continuum; it acknowledges the structural aspects and factors of discrimination, which
includes structural and institutional inequalities; and it analyzes social and/or economic
hierarchies between women and men and also among women. Thus, it explicitly
interrogates the places where violence against women coincides with multiple and
intersecting forms of discrimination and their attendant inequalities.
51.
Adopting a holistic approach to recognizing the human right of all women to be free
from violence and discrimination addresses two approaches to analyzing violence against
women. First, violence against women constitutes discrimination against women if it has
the purpose or effect of targeting women because they are women; second, violence also
constitutes discrimination when it is perpetrated with the purpose or effect of targeting
identifiable subgroups of women, because their personhood is defined in terms of both their
femaleness and other factors such as race, colour, national origin, citizenship, ethnicity,
ability, religion/culture, socio-economic, marital, sexual orientation, refugee, or any other
status.15
52.
The holistic approach considers each woman’s social location and bodily integrity as
a starting point for intervention and treatment, and, by doing so, makes clear that gender
inequality and gender stratification are but two of the many factors that perpetuate and
promote violence against women in all parts of the world. Such an approach counters
efforts that focus on violence against women as solely a woman’s issue, as it risks
minimizing the role that socio-economic, cultural, religious, racial, ethnic, ability,
education, access to citizenship and resource allocation inequalities play in maintaining
epidemic levels of violence against women.
53.
A holistic approach is based on the acknowledgement that unless women can
achieve economic independence or be empowered socially and politically, the human rights
they hear about will remain abstract concepts. This is especially true for those women for
whom the lack of access to particular economic and social rights, such as the right to land,
housing, and food are directly linked to the increased risk of violence.16
54.
The systematic nature of violence and its contribution to societal marginalization is
often overlooked or not adequately considered in matters of gender-based violence. This
could be due to the nature of systematic discrimination and also discourses about identity;
whether based on race, ethnicity, national origin, and so on which often negate or ignore
systematic power. The different ways in which women may experience violence,
particularly intimate and interpersonal violence, depends on how they are positioned within
social, economic and cultural hierarchies that prohibit or further compromise certain
15
16
A/CONF.189/PC.3/5 (2001).
A/RES/65/187
13
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents