A/HRC/43/41/Add.2
the law, have limited opportunities to exercise other rights and are at a higher risk of abuse,
neglect and institutionalization.
76.
Some provinces are revising their legal framework with the aim of introducing less
restrictive measures such as advance directives, enduring powers of attorney or
representation agreements, and enabling greater choice of substitute decision makers.
Although these measures represent an important initial step, the relevant legislative
authorities at all levels of governance need to complete the process of legal harmonization,
to ensure that all persons with disabilities fully enjoy their legal capacity in accordance with
article 12 of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. The Special
Rapporteur reiterates her recommendation of withdrawing the interpretative declaration and
reservation to this article.
K.
Deprivation of liberty and involuntary treatment
77.
Provincial and territorial legislation across Canada allows for the involuntary
hospitalization and treatment of persons with psychosocial disabilities, in contradiction to
articles 14, 17 and 25 of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. For
example, the Mental Health Act of British Columbia contains very broad criteria for
involuntary admissions. 23 Moreover, once detained, a person can be forcibly treated,
including through forced medication and electroconvulsive therapy, without his or her free
and informed consent.
78.
In addition, most jurisdictions have passed legislation permitting clinician-initiated
community treatment orders, which compels persons with psychosocial disabilities to
comply with a treatment plan that generally includes medication and counselling. The
Special Rapporteur received several complaints regarding the implementation of these
orders, including in respect of the absence of procedural guarantees, the lack of alternative
treatment options and threats of forced hospitalization for lack of compliance.
79.
The Special Rapporteur was informed that the number of involuntary
hospitalizations was increasing. Furthermore, a significant number of persons with
psychosocial disabilities cannot leave hospital due to the lack of community-based
alternatives. The extensive use of seclusion and restraints, including chemical restraints, is
also a concern, especially since there is no independent monitoring of mental health
facilities. The expert urges the Government of Canada to ratify the Optional Protocol on the
Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or
Punishment and to establish a national preventive mechanism.
L.
Access to justice
80.
The Supreme Court of Canada and the provincial and territorial courts of Canada
have developed a significant body of jurisprudence concerning the rights of persons with
disabilities. Most of the cases heard in court involve complaints of discrimination on
grounds of disability. The Canadian Judicial Council has developed training courses and
guidelines on access to justice for persons with disabilities.
81.
The Canadian Human Rights Act and the Criminal Code establish a duty to
accommodate persons with disabilities’ needs in all proceedings before federal and
provincial courts and federal tribunals. Different provinces and territories also recognize
this obligation in their respective legislation. However, there is a lack of judicial protocols
and guidelines on procedural and age-appropriate accommodations for persons with
disabilities. Ensuring access to reasonable accommodations should not be confused with
procedural accommodations in the context of access to justice. Article 13 of the Convention
on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities requires procedural accommodations, which are
not limited by the concept of “disproportionate or undue burden”. That differentiation is
23
See www.health.gov.bc.ca/library/publications/year/2005/MentalHealthGuide.pdf.
15
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents