A/HRC/8/47
Page 12
a need for specific urban planning and policy. France respects diversity at all levels, in politics and
in society. France has implemented innovative approaches to strengthen diversity, e.g. by
encouraging access to the highest schools and universities for persons from underprivileged areas,
or through an action plan for access to the civil service. The Conseil Supérieur de l’Audiovisuel,
which is an independent body, has undertaken measures to ensure that the media reflects the
diversity that prevails in the French society. The promotion of diversity is also reflected in the
teaching of regional languages in France.
43.
The Commission nationale de déontologie de la sécurité is an independent body that can be
seized by members of Parliament, can call for inquiries and reports once a year to the President.
France also reiterated the important role of the Contrôleur général des lieux de détention whose
mandate is broad and whose independence is protected by the law. France is currently selecting a
candidate to fill the post and has allocated a budget of 2.5 million euros and 20 staff members to
this new institution. Regarding concerns raised with regard to impunity forlaw enforcement
officials, a victim can directly seize the judge who is then obliged to open an inquiry. Victims who
complain about excessive administrative sanctions applied in prisons can access a lawyer
remunerated by the State. This type of cases has considerably decreased. Regarding the list of safe
countries in asylum procedures, the representative of France assured that this list is constantly
updated. French citizenship is not required to reside in France and 8 per cent of the population who
lives and works in France are not French. Referring again to the law on religious symbols and its
impact, France specified that out of 48 cases, only two persons could not be provided with
schooling. More than two years after its adoption, ICRMW, France recalled that it has difficulties
due to the fact that this convention does not distinguish between regular and irregular migration and
that in any case it applies most of the provisions contained in the convention. France also recalled
that this issue has to be dealt with at the European level as, since the Amsterdam Treaty, it falls
within the competence of the European Union.
44.
Referring to the alarming human rights situation in the administrative detention centre of
Pamandzi in Mayotte, to the detention of minors, inhuman and degrading treatment, the
impossibility for detainees to exercise their right to communicate, the absence of the right to health,
suspensive recourse against administrative measures and of procedural guarantees, Côte d’Ivoire
asked how France plans to reconcile these conditions with the international human rights
instruments to which it is a party. Côte d’Ivoire recommended that experiments on detainees with
electric impulsion weapons provoking acute pain, which can constitute a form of torture, be avoided
in penitentiaries.
45.
The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland welcomed the introduction of a
new policy for deprived urban areas, and asked whether there is provision for sufficient financing of
the initiative and whether the measures go far enough in tackling the root causes of inequality and
discrimination among disadvantaged groups. The United Kingdom welcomed that report of the
CNCDH indicating that incidents of racist attacks reported to the authorities have decreased
regularly since 2005, and recommended that France make efforts to enforce existing antidiscrimination legislation more effectively, and that the Government consider compiling statistics
on ethnic minority groups, as this would help to assess the extent and causes of inequality and
evaluate the effectiveness of measures in place to address it. The United Kingdom asked what
France is doing to ensure that those working in the political and public administration spheres
reflect the diversity of France as a whole. It urged France to move forward with the appointment of
a suitable candidate to the post of Contrôleur des lieux privatifs de liberté and asked for more
information on what it is doing to address overpopulation in prisons, and to modernize its prison
facilities, particularly with regard to juveniles. The United Kingdom recommended increased
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents