A/HRC/36/55
forces having used cluster incendiary munitions,17 that international coalition forces do not
use these type of munitions, and that Russian and Syrian officials acknowledged that at the
time of the strike, between 11.30 a.m. and 13.30 p.m., the Syrian air force conducted
airstrikes in Khan Shaykhun, the Commission finds that there are reasonable grounds to
believe that either Syrian and/or Russian forces conducted the airstrike against the alRahma medical point.
VI. The use of sarin
19.
Sarin is a synthetic, odourless liquid nerve agent which can be dispersed in air as an
aerosol. Upon release, the agent cloud drifts with the wind as well as following terrain
features. Unprotected humans will experience both external contamination (skin, hair,
clothing), and absorb the agent via inhalation and via the skin. The symptoms of sarin
poisoning vary depending on the dose received (page 32), though a classic symptom is
miosis (extreme contraction of the pupils). In severe cases, the symptoms include cramps,
muscular contraction, seizures, severe pain, and severe respiratory distress; the cause of
death is asphyxiation by blockage of the lung muscles as well as the respiratory centre in
the central nervous system. The agent or its characteristic biomarkers can be detected in
biomedical samples collected from victims for some time (several days in the case of urine,
and weeks in the case of blood or other tissue samples collected from survivors or during
autopsies). The agent, its characteristic degradation products, and certain impurities
contained in the agent mixture can also be found in environmental samples taken from the
impact area.
20.
According to the OPCW report,18 the OPCW FFM attended the autopsies of three
alleged victims in a neighbouring country one day after the alleged attack, and visited ten
patients in three hospitals four days later to retrieve biomedical samples for analysis. It also
conducted several interviews: one patient and one treating physician were interviewed
during the hospital visit on 8 April, and subsequent interviews with two patients who had
tested positive for sarin exposure were conducted on 31 May and 1 June, respectively. The
OPCW FFM also received environmental and biological-environmental samples collected
by non-governmental organisations at the alleged incident location, as well as additional
biomedical samples collected at medical facilities in opposition-controlled areas. In
addition, the OPCW FFM collected information from the Syrian Government during two
visits to Damascus, and visited the Scientific Studies and Research Centre (SSRC) in Barza
where it received environmental samples and metal fragments from the impact area which
the SSRC had previously analysed.
21.
While the Commission was unable to collect or test bio-medical and environmental
samples, it notes that based on bio-medical samples obtained during autopsies and from
individuals undergoing treatment in a neighbouring country the OPCW FFM found that
these individuals were exposed to sarin or a sarin-like substance. The OPCW FFM
witnessed the acquisition of these biomedical samples and applied chain of custody
procedures to demonstrate sample authenticity and integrity, and the analysis was
undertaken by two independent Designated Laboratories, both of which have previously
demonstrated their competence for this type of analysis in official OPCW Proficiency
Tests. This analysis found that the tissue samples collected from the three victims (blood,
brain, hair, lung and liver tissue) who had died contained (with the exception of one hair
sample) characteristic biomarkers demonstrating the exposure of the victims to sarin or a
sarin-like substance. The analytical findings were consistent with the autopsy reports,
which had concluded that the cause of death in all three cases had been exposure to a toxic
gas.
22.
Bio-medical samples of seven of the 10 persons undergoing treatment in the
neighbouring country showed that they, too, were exposed to sarin or a sarin-like substance.
These analytical findings were consistent with the clinical symptoms observed.
17
18
26
A/HRC/34/64, paras. 14, 59-60; A/HRC/34/CRP.3, paras. 59-60.
OPCW FFM report, paras. 3.16, 3.52-3.53, 3.64, and 4.7-4.9.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents