A/HRC/36/55
and produced less smoke than the others. Photographs of weapon remnants depict a
chemical aerial bomb of a type manufactured in the former Soviet Union.
75.
The chemical bomb killed at least 83 persons, including 28 children and 23 women,
and injured another 293 persons, including 103 children. On the basis of samples obtained
during autopsies and from individuals undergoing treatment in a neighbouring country,
those who undertook the fact-finding mission of the Organisation for the Prohibition of
Chemical Weapons concluded that the victims had been exposed to sarin or a sarin-like
substance. The extensive information independently collected by the Commission on
symptoms suffered by victims is consistent with sarin exposure.
76.
Interviewees denied the presence of a weapons depot near the impact point of the
chemical bomb. The Commission notes that it is extremely unlikely that an air strike would
release sarin potentially stored inside such a structure in amounts sufficient to explain the
number of casualties recorded. First, if such a depot had been destroyed by an air strike, the
explosion would have burnt off most of the agent inside the building or forced it into the
rubble where it would have been absorbed, rather than released in significant amounts into
the atmosphere. Second, the facility would still be heavily contaminated today, for which
there is no evidence. Third, the scenario suggested by Russian and Syrian officials does not
explain the timing of the appearance of victims — hours before the time Russian and Syrian
officials gave for the strike.
77.
In view of the above, the Commission finds that there are reasonable grounds to
believe that Syrian forces attacked Khan Shaykhun with a sarin bomb at approximately
6.45 a.m. on 4 April, constituting the war crimes of using chemical weapons and
indiscriminate attacks in a civilian inhabited area. The use of sarin by Syrian forces also
violates the Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Production, Stockpiling
and Use of Chemical Weapons and on Their Destruction and Security Council resolution
2118 (2013).
VII. Ongoing investigations
78.
The Commission is gravely concerned about the protection of civilians in ArRaqqah Governorate, owing to the ongoing offensive by the Syrian Democratic Forces and
the international coalition to repel ISIL from Ar-Raqqah city. While numerous
neighbourhoods have been rapidly overtaken, over 190,000 civilians have been displaced to
areas under the control of Syrian Democratic Forces in the north of Ar-Raqqah
Governorate, where they reside primarily in the Ain Issa and Mabrouka camps. The camps
lack the resources and capacity necessary to adequately care for those persons. The lives of
up to 60,000 other civilians inside Ar-Raqqah city remain at considerable risk under daily
air strikes. Protection concerns faced during the conduct of interviews remain an issue.
79.
The Commission is currently undertaking investigations into several allegations of
aerial attacks in Ar-Raqqah, including an air strike on Al-Mansoura village, at the time held
by ISIL, which reportedly caused up to 200 civilian casualties. The Commission has
gathered credible information that, on the night of 21 March, an air strike hit the Al-Badiya
school in Al-Mansoura, which since 2012 had been used to house internally displaced
persons. At the time of the strike, over 200 people, mostly displaced families from Palmyra,
Homs, but also from Hamah and Aleppo, were living at the former school, which is located
approximately 1.5 kilometres from the village. Some of the victims were recent arrivals,
including from Maskanah, Aleppo, while other internally displaced persons had been living
there for years. The strike was carried out at night when residents were asleep. Almost all
of those inside the school at the time of the strike were killed, while some survivors,
including women and children, sustained serious injuries. Information currently available
indicates that at least two families of ISIL fighters had been living in the school previously,
but left about one month before the strike.
80.
After its offensive to take Manbij, Aleppo, from ISIL, the Syrian Democratic Forces
required significant reinforcements to set the stage to retake Ar-Raqqah city. The need for
increased “manpower” resulted in a surge in forced conscription of thousands of civilians,
16
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents