A/HRC/13/51
64.
Following the above presentations, in an interactive debate, the representatives of
Indonesia, Mexico, Sweden and Viet Nam and the member of the Committee on Economic,
Social and Cultural Rights made statements, as did the International Federation of
University of Women, CIVICUS, the Flemish League of Human Rights and Dr. Salomon.
65.
There was consensus that policy coherence discussions should address the
consistency of the development agenda with human rights normative standards, reiterating
that, in its general comments, the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
consistently requested that developed and developing countries take into account their
human rights obligations in their policies and decisions, including through international
cooperation and assistance. International cooperation was not limited to financial
assistance, but included addressing the global economic system and its underlying
impediments. It was repeatedly emphasized that donors should continue to provide
resources to less developed countries to help them achieve their development objectives,
complying with the ODA commitment of 0.7 per cent of GDP, and most importantly to
improve aid effectiveness. Policy coherence also required human rights obligations of
Member States to be observed, despite the different undertakings assumed under other
international agreements. Applying a human rights perspective to development activities
was not a policy option but a legal requirement, and failure to do so would prevent the
achievement of meaningful development and equitable outcomes.
66.
A focus on non-discrimination, equality and gender dimensions and the
prioritization of the most marginalized and vulnerable population groups living in poverty
were widely recognized as critical elements of a human rights perspective. The Millennium
Development Goals had to be customized to the development needs and concerns of each
country in order to be meaningful. Speakers underscored the role played by United Nations
agencies, Member States, international and non-governmental organizations and civil
society, as well as the proactive roles of different human rights mechanisms, in
incorporating the human rights concerns into the Millennium Development Goals and the
efforts to combat poverty.
2.
Strengthening the effectiveness of international assistance and cooperation
67.
Senior Lecturer at the Centre for the Study of Human Rights of the London School
of Economics, Margot Salomon, drew on a range of findings in highlighting the fact that
the dominant neo-liberal economic policies of the past two and a half decades had failed to
achieve their stipulated goals of faster economic growth, reduced poverty and more stable
economies. A key message arising from these developments was that the state of world
poverty today was not an accident, but rather a consequence of the policies pursued.
International cooperation for the realization of human rights would be strengthened by
addressing both poverty (the position of those worst off) as well as global economic
inequality, for many reasons, including because the process of inequality was a product of
asymmetrical power and influence globally, and because global inequality was a cause of
arbitrary disadvantage and the denial of human rights. The ability of the poor to participate
in the shared life of a global society was rendered impossible owing to their absolute
position of poverty; this was further exacerbated by the exclusion caused by their relational
poverty. Moreover, world poverty constituted indirect discrimination against the poor: the
rules governing the global economy may not set out to exclude certain people from access
to an adequate standard of living, but that was the effect that they had had.
68.
In the context of past policy failures and the negative effects of the financial crisis,
Dr. Salomon maintained that the burden of proof now rested on relevant Governments,
policymakers and international financial institutions to show that reforms were in the best
interest of the poor. The international law doctrine of due diligence should be given a
stronger role in order to bolster global poverty eradication policies and facilitate the
14
GE.09-17229
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents