A/HRC/26/29
affirming the legitimacy of associations formed to promote issues of concern to minorities
for historical and economic reasons.24
54.
The process of registering an association may prove to be cumbersome for
marginalized groups and exclude groups such minorities or persons with disabilities. For
example, the language used to communicate could be inaccessible, and physical access to
locations for registration could also be a challenge for those groups. Mandatory registration,
particularly where authorities have broad discretion to grant or deny registration, provides
an opportunity for the State to refuse or delay registration to groups that do not espouse
“favourable” views. Associations formed to defend human rights, engage in civic
awareness, and to lobby and advocate are susceptible to such delays and denials, as has
reportedly been the case in the Sudan.
55.
The Special Rapporteur emphasizes that the right to freedom of association applies
equally to associations that are not registered (A/HRC/20/27, para. 96). He endorses as best
practice a voluntary registration regime that permits unregistered associations to operate.
The Special Rapporteur notes with approval the recent ruling by a magistrate’s court in
Zimbabwe, quashing charges of running an unregistered organization preferred against a
member of the Gays and Lesbians of Zimbabwe association.
56.
Nevertheless, where a registration regime exists, requirements should be framed
such that no one is disadvantaged in the formation of her or his association, either by
burdensome procedural requirements or unjustifiable limitations to substantive activities of
associations. The State has an obligation to take positive measures to overcome specific
challenges that confront marginalized groups, such as indigenous peoples, minorities,
persons with disabilities, women and youth, in their efforts to form associations.25
57.
Funding restrictions, including restrictions on foreign funding, may
disproportionately affect associations that promote issues that do not enjoy popularity or the
support of the State or the majority of the population, including those that relate to the
advancement of the rights of marginalized groups. This is evidenced by the dichotomy that
some States impose regarding association funding sources: certain types of activities or
organizations are permitted to receive foreign funding while others only receive domestic
funding. For instance, to be considered an Ethiopian charity or society, organizations
cannot receive more than 10 per cent of their funding from foreign sources. Only Ethiopian
charities or societies may engage in promoting human rights work, gender equality and
religious equality, the rights of persons with disabilities, children’s rights, conflict
resolution or reconciliation and the efficiency of the justice and law enforcement services.
Foreign associations or those that receive more than 10 per cent of their funding from
foreign sources may not engage in such activities. In the Russian Federation, an
organization working on “political activities” and receiving foreign funding must register
itself as a “foreign agent”, which in Russian is synonymous with “foreign spy”. The law
broadly defines political activities as attempts to influence official decision-making or to
shape public opinion to exert a similar influence, and thus can include work in areas such as
human rights, governance and accountability issues.
58.
Legislation that provides broad discretion to authorities to monitor or oversee the
activities of associations poses a grave risk to the continued existence of organizations that
engage in activities perceived to be threatening to the State. Groups that advocate against
the unsustainable use of natural resources or the use of those resources contrary to the rights
of indigenous peoples are often targeted and risk closure, as happened to Fundación
24
25
16
European Court of Human Rights, Sidiropoulos and others v. Greece, case No. 57/1997/841/1047, 10
July 1998, paras. 44 and 46.
Human Rights Committee, general comment No. 25 (1996), para. 12.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents