A/HRC/26/29
Pachamama in Ecuador pursuant to Presidential Decree No. 16. The Special Rapporteur
emphasizes that associations are entitled to operational autonomy, which includes the
freedom to choose which activities they engage in to achieve organizational goals.
3.
Other legal provisions that have a disproportionate impact on the right to freedom
of association of some groups
59.
The use of national security or counter-terrorism legislation to restrict or prohibit the
formation or registration of associations is often detrimental to the right to freedom of
association of minority groups. Under the guise of fighting terrorism or extremism,
associations comprised of minorities, including religious, linguistic or ethnic minorities, may
be subjected to delays in registration, denial of registration, harassment and interference. Such
associations may be seen as promoting or propagating views or beliefs not shared by the
majority of the population or that are unfavourable to the authorities. The Special Rapporteur
recognizes that States have a legitimate obligation to protect their national security and public
safety. However, this legitimate interest should never be used as an excuse to silence critical
or diverse voices. States must treat all associations equitably, regardless of their views, and
this treatment must be guided by objective criteria that comply with international human
rights law, where a registration regime exists. In Chile, members of the Mapuche indigenous
community have been targeted under counter-terrorism legislation when advocating for the
rights of their community. In Turkey, peaceful Kurdish activists advocating for the rights of
their community have been arrested and sentenced to prison for allegedly belonging to an
association considered to be a terrorist group.
60.
Criminal procedure laws and penal sanctions are used in several States to deter the
exercise of the right to freedom of association. Authorities who are hostile to critical voices
resort to criminal prosecution for defamation or similar offences, thereby discouraging and
interfering with legitimate activities by groups. Organizations engaged in human rights
work, anti-corruption advocacy and other accountability initiatives are particularly targeted.
In Oman, between May and June 2012, 11 human rights defenders, including bloggers,
writers, and members of human rights organizations and of the media, were sentenced for
offences related to injurious speech and assembly. They were all pardoned on 22 March
2013. In Viet Nam, in March 2013, the police charged a human rights defender with slander
against the regime. The authorities asserted that he had not expressed his opinions in a
peaceful manner and that he had thus disturbed the public order. The country’s Press Law
of 1989 limits the right to express dissent, restricting it to “constructive” opinions on
implementing the lines and policies of the Communist Party and the laws of the States law.
In El Salvador, article 345 of the Criminal Code considers as illegal two or more people
gathering to commit a crime. Despite the necessity to prove intent to commit a crime, law
enforcement officials often stop and detain young people simply because it is believed that
they are gathering to organize or plan a crime, or that they belong to a gang merely because
they have a tattoo, are young, live in a particular neighbourhood where there is gang
presence or are poor. Youth are additionally disproportionately affected because criminal
groups force them to join their ranks, thereby violating their right to freedom of association.
61.
The right to freedom of association extends to cross-border or international
collaboration between associations and their membership. Indeed, the United Nations
Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples acknowledges the right of indigenous
peoples divided by international borders to maintain and develop contacts, relations and
cooperation, including activities for spiritual, cultural, political, economic and social
purposes, with their own members as well as other peoples across borders (art. 36).26 That
26
See also the Declaration on the Rights of Persons Belonging to National or Ethnic, Religious and
Linguistic Minorities, art. 2, para. 5.
17
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents