A/HRC/39/19
international human rights standards. Retentionist States should systematically and
publicly provide full and accurate data on death sentences that are carried out. Those
data should include information on charges and data disaggregated by gender, age,
nationality, ethnic origin and other relevant demographics, on the persons affected. Such
data are necessary to ensure compliance with international human rights standards.
53.
The imposition of a death sentence at the conclusion of a trial in which due process
and fair trial safeguards have not been respected constitutes a violation of the right to life.
Pending abolition, the Secretary-General urges States to ensure that legal guarantees and
safeguards are effectively put in place and implemented, in particular with regard to the
right to seek pardon and commutation through procedures which offer certain essential
guarantees.
54.
Even for the “most serious crimes”, the death penalty should never be mandatory.
The Secretary-General welcomes developments which have led to the removal of the
mandatory death penalty in many countries and, in particular, the procedures
undertaken to resentence those who were subject to a mandatory death penalty. Courts
should be provided with the discretion to consider the circumstances of each individual
case, including any mitigating factors. States that maintain the mandatory death penalty
should abolish it immediately, and a process that takes into account the personal
circumstances of the offender and the particular circumstances of the offence, including
its specific aggravating or attenuating elements, should be put in place for all those who
were mandatorily sentenced to death.
55.
Countries continuing to implement the death penalty should take heed of the
recommendations made by other States during the universal periodic review process and
the concluding observations, general comments and jurisprudence of human rights treaty
bodies, not only to ensure conformity with international standards but also to work
towards universal abolition.
17
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents