A/HRC/45/CRP.11
Transfer and Enforced Disappearance
1190. After 18 October 2016, soldiers at the El Café base told family members that the men
were no longer there.2109 They explained that the detainees had been transferred that day to
Fort Guaicamacaure, Chaguaramal town in Pedro Gual municipality (1.5 hours by car from
El Café).2110 The soldiers claimed that the criminal background checking system in El Café
was malfunctioning, and the transfer was necessary for this reason. 2111
1191. The Mission was informed that a transfer to Fort Guaicamacuare did not take place.2112
Detainees were instead transferred at the end of October from El Café to another military
base in Alfarería Bell, where they stayed for around a week before being executed.2113
Another source with qualified knowledge of the operation confirmed that the men were
transferred from El Café to Alfarería Bell, and that the transfer took place approximately 15
days into the operation. This source revealed that the commander of the ZODI Miranda
ordered the transfer to prevent Public Prosecutor’s Office representatives and family
members from locating the detainees.2114
1192. Family members were unaware of their loved one’s whereabouts and continued to
search for them.2115 According to one relative, “His mother-in-law and I went to Sotillo, to
Curiepe, to the airport […] to a command here in La Trinidad. We went to Chaguaramal to
different places and nothing, no, we never found him”.2116 A detainee’s uncle said, “We went
to Chaguaramal, we went to other places, nothing, nothing, no answers, nobody, not even the
Lieutenant Colonel gave us an answer, he did not even show up”. 2117 A victim’s sister said
that, upon arriving in Fort Chaguaramal “an official told us they were there to bring him food
and clothes. The next day […] they said they had already been transferred. We asked to where
and they told us to Higuerote heliport. [There] they told us that they were not there”.2118
1193. One of the detainees later released explained that he had been forced to sign a
document saying he had not been beaten and had been provided with food, well treated, and
his rights had not been violated.2119 This coincided with information received from a reliable
source with direct knowledge of the operation. He informed the Mission that the commander
of ZODI Miranda had instructed that detainees be forced to sign and fingerprint declarations
2109
2110
2111
2112
2113
2114
2115
2116
2117
2118
2119
234
Delsa Solórzano, En vivo con los familiares de las víctimas de la MASACRE de Barlovento, minute
33:13, available at: https://www.pscp.tv/w/1ZkJznbXPaWJv. See also Efecto Cocuyo, Obreros,
estudiantes, agricultores: ¿Quiénes eran las víctimas de la masacre de Barlovento?, 16 December
2016, available at: https://efectococuyo.com/la-humanidad/obreros-estudiantes-agricultores-quieneseran-las-victimas-de-la-masacre-de-barlovento/.
Public Prosecutor’s Office, Barlovento: informe sobre víctimas y hechos ocurridos en Barlovento:
masacre a 12 personas, February 2017, p. 11, available at: https://lortegadiaz.com/wpcontent/uploads/2017/12/barlovento-ultima-version4-16-05-2017.pdf. See also RunRun.es, ¿En qué
se parecen las masacres de Barlovento y Tumeremo?, 2 December 2016, available at:
https://runrun.es/investigacion/289036/en-que-se-parecen-las-masacres-de-barlovento-y-tumeremo/.
Efecto Cocuyo, Carlos Marchena, uno de los fallecidos en la masacre de Barlovento, 13 December
2016, minute 0:48, available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EgxbQbY2Phs.
Mission Interview C4FF09 in May 2020. See also Public Prosecutor’s Office, Barlovento: informe
sobre víctimas y hechos ocurridos en Barlovento: masacre a 12 personas, February 2017, p. 11,
available at: https://lortegadiaz.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/barlovento-ultima-version4-16-052017.pdf
Document C4FF08 on file with the Mission.
Document C4FF07 on file with the Mission.
Unidad Venezuela, Familiares de ajusticiados en Masacre de Barlovento ofrecen desgarradores
testimonios en la morgue, minute 1:12, 28 November 2016, available at:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2g80XRbopwU.
Digital.Net, Hablan los familiares de las víctimas de la “Masacre de Barlovento”, minute 1:39, 2
December 2016, available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ejKkchS1NA.
Delsa Solórzano, En vivo con los familiares de las víctimas de la MASACRE de Barlovento, from
minute 33:30, available at: https://www.pscp.tv/w/1ZkJznbXPaWJv.
Ibid., minute 34:45.
Gabriel Bastidas en Vivo Play, Testimonio de sobreviviente de la masacre de Barlovento, minute
1:06, 30 November 2016, available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_J6p-pz-_dM.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents