A/HRC/8/4
page 17
suspension and the cessation of their functions. Among the factors that may affect not only the
judicial function but also the exercise of the right of access to justice are a shortage of judges or
the inaccessibility of judges by reason of distance, as already mentioned, the material
circumstances in which members of the judiciary work, the training received by judges and the
mechanisms and laws instituted to preserve their independence and impartiality. By way of
example, the Special Rapporteur draws attention to the report on his mission to Kazakhstan
(E/CN.4/2005/60/Add.2).
40. Lawyers - Although not part of the judicial structure, lawyers play an essential role in the
right to justice, in access to justice and, especially, in the right to a defence. In order to fulfil their
role, they need a legal and institutional framework that allows them to exercise their profession
freely and a judicial culture that allows them to meet their clients in private and to communicate
with the accused in conditions that fully respect the confidentiality of their communications. Yet
the experience of this mandate shows how often lawyers are subjected to pressure, intimidation
and constraints, leading up in many cases to arrest, assault and disappearance, for example. In
many countries their work is hampered by complex regulatory regimes that govern the issuance
and renewal of licences to practise law, and in extreme cases it may, for example, be the public
prosecutor who takes the decision or advises the executive branch on the matter. Directly and
indirectly, all these circumstances seriously affect access to justice. On the other hand, many
means have been devised to provide legal assistance to those without the necessary financial
resources.45 In some cases, the State arranges with private lawyers or bar associations to provide
services that are later reimbursed by the State.46 In other cases, lawyers operate as if they were
civil servants paid by the State to provide free legal assistance;47 these are the court-appointed
defence counsels. The public defender’s office can be established as a State institution in several
ways, either as part of the judiciary or the ministry of justice, or as a functionally and financially
autonomous entity, an option that is spreading in Latin America. Provision is usually also made
for the hiring of outside lawyers. In some countries, NGOs and universities have taken
initiatives, setting up legal clinics, for example, and other means of providing this service. In
some particularly sensitive cases or cases affecting a large number of people (environment,
consumer protection, public health or anti-impunity cases), victims are represented by NGOs or
by lawyers defending wider social interests. The aim is to overcome the barriers to access to
justice encountered by certain groups, including lack of information, fear, high litigation costs or
45
Vid. Por ejemplo E: Blankenburg, “Comparing Legal Aid Schemes in Europe”, Civil Justice
Quarterly, vol. 11, 1992, pp. 106-114; H. Hirte, Access to courts for indigent persons: a
comparative analysis of the legal framework in the United Kingdom, United States and
Germany”, Civil Justice Quarterly, vol. 11, 1992, pp. 92-123.
46
Caso de Francia, vid., F. Tietgen, “The Paris Bar: Access to justice and access to legal
advise”, Fordham International Law Journal, vol. 24, 1999-2000, p. 220.
47
En el caso de Canadá se combinan ambos sistemas. Vid.
http://www.canlaw.com/legalaid/aidoffice.htm
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents