A/HRC/42/44/Add.1
rights 2016–2021 recognizes the need to end the caporalato system and all forms of illegal
exploitation of migrant workers as part of the commitment to realizing the Sustainable
Development Goals and in particular goal 8 and target 8.7, which involve promoting decent
work as an antidote to modern slavery. Equality counsellors promote equal opportunities in
the workplace at the regional, provincial and national level.
32.
At the time of the visit, the Government was reviewing the national action plan
against human trafficking and serious exploitation 2016–2018 and a follow-up plan was
being developed.
33.
Following the visit, a pilot memorandum of understanding was signed by the
Ministers of Labour and the Interior and by the presidents of the five regions in southern
Italy most affected by the caporalato system. Through a joint partnership and strengthened
cooperation at the regional level, holistic reception programmes have been set up, but
implementation remains pending. The Government has recently reactivated a multistakeholder platform to address labour exploitation in agriculture more effectively. It aims
to establish a three-year action plan involving key stakeholders. The regional government
of Apulia adopted a decision on an innovative form of agriculture, the foltore farms. Under
this model, workers receive free accommodation, look after 20 hectares of land and receive
the harvest, thus rendering them self-sufficient. The pilot project was launched in 2016 and
its outcome was being evaluated at the time of the visit.
34.
An inter-institutional Committee was established by article 25-quater of Law 136.
The Committee is responsible for the development and implementation of a national plan to
combat labour exploitation in agriculture through different areas of intervention.
35.
The Common Agricultural Policy of the European Union has provided unequal
support to the agricultural sector in Italy, favouring mainly northern regions, large farms
and the food industry.15 Consequently, producers have been expected to outbid each other
by lowering the price of their products, with the result that labour costs have been cut by
employing a cheap workforce. As was reported to the Special Rapporteur, since many rural
areas in Italy have been affected by depopulation and abandonment, migrants have
increasingly responded to the demand for low-cost and flexible labour.
36.
Italy has yet to establish a national human rights institution in compliance with the
principles relating to the status of national institutions for the promotion and protection of
human rights. The process of establishing such an institution continues to stagnate but the
Special Rapporteur hopes for prompt progress in this regard. Government measures
adopted in 2019 are not reflected in the present report. 16
IV. Main findings
A.
Causes of labour exploitation in the agricultural sector in Italy
37.
A number of structural factors which put already vulnerable individuals at risk of
being subjected to labour exploitation in agriculture lead to forced labour or to slavery-like
conditions. In particular, the systemic prevalence of the caporalato system, consisting of
illegal recruitment through gangmasters, opens the door to exploitation and abuse. The
caporalato is historically and socially anchored in the countryside of Italy as a form of
irregular and anomalous organization of the agricultural labour market. Based on reports,
the system is currently applied in the whole country and not restricted to the south.
38.
The caporalato is not limited to agriculture, but that is reportedly the sector most
affected by it. The types of exploitation are complex and manifold and the consequence of
several factors. Intermediaries who may or may not be connected to organized crime act as
a link between agricultural entrepreneurs and workers.
15
16
See Franco Sotte, “Sessant’anni di Europa e Pac: il nuovo che c’è e il vecchio che è rimasto”,
Agriregionieuropa, No. 50 (September 2017).
For further information, see the comments provided by Italy.
7
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents