A/HRC/44/40/Add.3
(i)
Mid-Term Review of RMK-11
(ii)
WKB 2030; and
(iii)
Pelan Pembangunan Nasional Orang Asli (PPNOA)
Paragraph 89
Migrant workers, especially but not only those who are undocumented, face serious
violations of their labor and other rights. There is a need for a comprehensive new policy that
acknowledges the real extent of foreign labor dependence, regulates working conditions more
effectively, ensures real minimum wages, and treats workers and their dependents humanely.
Comments from the Government of Malaysia:
•
The Government has introduced Employer Undertaking in 2017, a strict liability
concept whereby employers of foreign workers are fully accountable to comply with the
recruitment process including payment of expenses incurred such as the levy, health
screening, insurance and processing fees. The initiative also include the welfare of workers
such as the provision of housing and basic amenities until they return home. Severe penalties
has been imposed on employers who are found guilty of employing illegal foreign workers
through effective enforcement initiatives. The recruitment process of foreign workers are
more organized thereby preventing them from being exposed to exploitation of forced labor.
On the other hand, the Minimum Wages Order 2012 was introduced to ensure both local
workers and foreign workers receive better wages. The Employment Act 1955 also been
revised in 2019 to better regulate working conditions of the workers including foreign
workers.
Paragraph 90
Existing refugee policies are punitive rather than humane, and economically counterproductive. Refugees and asylum-seekers should be permitted to work, their children
admitted to public schools, and they should be eligible for public healthcare.
Comments from the Government of Malaysia:
•
The government has implemented a few administrative policies in managing refugees.
The government also acknowledge on the argument that refugees and asylum-seekers should
be allowed to work, access to education and public health. Some actions have been taken as
follows:
(i)
Based on humanity basis, the government currently reviewing its policy to allow
refugees to work in approved sectors while waiting for their resettlement to a third country
or voluntarily return to their country origin;
(ii)
Refugees children are allowed access to the private education including Alternative
Learning Centre (ALC) provided by UNHCR, NGOs and refugees communities; and
(iii) They are also entitled for medical treatment at any public hospitals/clinics at a 50%
discount of a total bill.
Paragraph 91
The extent of statelessness and its devastating consequences for those affected, as well as for
the Malaysian economy, should be acknowledged. The government should produce
definitive estimates of statelessness, identify drivers of statelessness, and pursue a far more
concerted approach to facilitate—rather than deter—access for people eligible for Malaysian
citizenship.
Comments from the Government of Malaysia:
•
As Malaysia is not a party to the 1954 Convention relating to the status of the Stateless
Person and 1961 Convention on The Reduction of Statelessness, Malaysia has no legal
obligation to recognize stateless person
43
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents