A/HRC/12/26
page 12
29. Through the adoption of various unfair practices, employers often conceal information
about work-related accidents.11 Many major cases are not reported and settlements are reached
with the workers secretly. In case of fatal accidents, families of the victims are usually not
informed, as contractors do not use proper names or addresses of the workers and there is no
monitoring or inspection of the yards.
30. Official and estimated figures do not include workers who died of occupational diseases
related to long-term exposure to toxic and hazardous wastes and materials: the “hidden” deaths.
It is virtually impossible to get any data about the number of affected workers, since the
symptoms of many of these occupational diseases only appear several years after exposure, but it
is estimated that a significant number of individuals died, and many others will die in the future,
because of occupational diseases related to shipbreaking activities. For example, a medical study
submitted to the Indian Supreme Court in September 2006 concluded that 16 per cent of the
workforce handling asbestos in Alang showed symptoms of asbestosis, and was therefore at
serious risk of developing mesothelioma in the future.
2. Environmental impact
31. The methods of ship dismantling currently followed in South Asian shipbreaking yards
often fail to comply with generally accepted norms and standards aimed at ensuring the
protection of the environment from the adverse effects caused by the discharge of hazardous
wastes and products that may be present on end-of-life vessels.
32. The principle of environmentally sound management of ship dismantling requires that
hazardous wastes and materials are managed and disposed of in a manner that ensures the
protection of human health and the environment against the adverse effects which may result
from such wastes. If the dismantling facility does not have the technical capacity to handle the
hazardous wastes and materials present on the ship in an environmentally sound manner, the
vessel should be pre-cleaned prior to its last voyage.
33. Nevertheless, the reality in the yards of South Asian countries is different. End-of-life
ships are rarely pre-cleaned before their arrival on the shores of South Asia, and most of the
shipbreaking yards do not have any containment to prevent pollution of soil, air, and marine and
freshwater resources, nor the technology needed to ensure the environmentally safe management
and disposal of hazardous wastes and materials. In addition to causing a long-term adverse effect
on the environment, the current methods of ship dismantling also adversely affect local
communities surrounding the shipbreaking facilities, which often rely on agriculture and fishing
for their subsistence.
34. One of the traditional “cleaning” methods is the drilling of holes into the beached ship,
through which seawater can wash out oil-contaminated tanks at high tide. In this way,
hydrocarbons, heavy metals, PCBs, biocides (e.g. TBT) and cargo residues are released directly
into the environment, contaminating the soil, seawater and groundwater resources. The discharge
of bilge and ballast water pollutes the sea and coastal areas, and may cause the introduction of
11
Rahman and Ullah, op. cit.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents