A/HRC/4/37
page 12
families have been physically attacked, kidnapped, tortured and even killed. These violations
have allegedly been perpetrated both by the State or its agencies, and non-State entities.
37.
The following seven subsections deal with the activities of defenders within specific
areas of ESCR. In each section, the activities of defenders within this specific area is analysed
through cases of violations against the rights of defenders in this area. These cases are based on
communications sent to Governments by the Special Representative since the establishment of
the mandate, and the geographical focus of violations is identified only with reference to these
communications. The next section provides a general overview of the challenges faced by
defenders working across the spectrum of ESCR and the violations of the rights recognized by
the Declaration on Human Rights Defenders.
1. Land rights, natural resources and environmental issues
38.
On the issue of land rights and national resources, article 1 (2) of ICESCR stipulates that
“All peoples may, for their own ends, freely dispose of their natural wealth and resources
without prejudice to any obligations arising out of international economic cooperation, based
upon the principle of mutual benefit, and international law. In no case may a people be deprived
of its own means of subsistence.” This comes in addition to the previously mentioned article 17
of the UDHR on the right to property. Section IV of the Millennium Declaration is devoted to
“Protecting our common environment” and the Member States reaffirm their “support for the
principles of sustainable development […]” and resolve to “adopt in all our environmental
actions a new ethic of conservation and stewardship […]”.
39.
Since the establishment of the mandate, the Special Representative has sent 81
communications dealing with violations of the rights of defenders working on issues of land
rights, natural resources such as oil, gas, forests and water, environmental issues such as
pollution and waste-dumping and related issues.
40.
Defenders working on land rights, natural resources or environmental issues seem to be
particularly vulnerable to attacks and violations of their rights under the Declaration on Human
Rights Defenders in countries of Latin America and in parts of Asia. The Special Representative
has sent a high number of communications to the Governments of Brazil (12 cases) and
Guatemala (9 cases). Forty-five communications were sent to Governments in South America
and 23 cases were sent to Governments in Asia.
41.
Land rights and natural resources is an area where a large part of the defenders come
from indigenous populations and minority groups. These populations are often working to
secure their right to utilize and live on the land they consider to be theirs. The Special
Representative provides more information on the challenges they face in chapter III, section A,
below, dealing with indigenous peoples and minority groups.
42.
Women as a group are particularly vulnerable concerning issues of land rights and, in
particular, inheritance rights. Defenders are working against discriminatory inheritance laws and
customary practices that deprive women of their equal rights to own, inherit and control
property, including land and housing. The Special Representative provides more information on
the challenges they face in chapter III, section C, below, on women human rights defenders.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents