A/HRC/12/41
page 8
26. Cambodian law contains specific guarantees against arbitrary or illegal detention, yet
numerous cases of unlawful detention are reported each year and fail to be addressed by the
competent institutions. One noteworthy case involved the enforced disappearance and illegal
detention of a policeman on the orders of the National Police Commissioner in order to coerce
him into conceding his claim to property in Kep to a prominent public figure. Although the man
was released after intervention from OHCHR, he was subsequently charged and convicted of
criminal damage with regard to the disputed property.
27. Cases of excessive pretrial detention, excessive detention pending appeal and tardy release
at the end of sentence are commonplace. Limited capacity at the Court of Appeal is a major
cause of excessive pretrial detention since many accused people, whether convicted or acquitted,
wait long periods for appeals to be heard. OHCHR is working with the President of the Court of
Appeal, alongside several development partners, on ways to increase capacity and reduce the
backlog of appeals pending.
28. In the context of the implementation in early 2008 of the new anti-trafficking law, sex
workers were arbitrarily arrested by the police, assisted by Ministry of Social Affairs personnel,
during night-time “sweeps” in Phnom Penh. Together with the homeless, beggars, street
children, drug addicts and people with disabilities they were sent to two rehabilitation centres
(Koh Romduol and Prey Speu) run by the Phnom Penh Department of the Ministry of Social
Affairs. These sweeps have occurred for years in Phnom Penh ahead of important holidays and
events for “beautification” purpose, but were exacerbated in the context of the enforcement of
the new law. People in the centres were illegally confined and subject to a variety of abuses of
power by the staff that included sub-humane conditions of detention, extortion, beating, rape,
sometimes resulting in death, and suicide. OHCHR worked closely with the Ministry of Social
Affairs, as well as with NGOs, in response to these serious allegations in order to verify them
and recommend appropriate action. It visited these centres and observed the appalling conditions
in which people were held. It submitted its initial findings confidentially to the Ministry of
Social Affairs, which took prompt steps to release the estimated 60 people being held and, on
8 August 2008, the Minister issued an internal instruction ordering Ministry staff to stop
involvement in the police sweeps. The instruction also reiterated the principle that admissions to
the centres should be on a strictly voluntary basis. OHCHR was authorized by the Ministry to
visit these centres on a regular basis, so as to report to the Minister any concerns it might have.
By September 2008, it observed that no further abuses were being reported, that Ministry staff
had stopped their involvement in the police sweeps, and the practice of rounding up poor people
in the streets had come to a halt. In March 2009, it submitted a confidential report to the
Minister, confirming some of the most serious allegations of abuses prior to July 2008. In May, it
discussed these concerns confidentially with the Secretary of State at the Ministry. It welcomed
the measures taken to prevent further abuses and recommended that past abuses be investigated
and sanctioned in order to deter further abuse.
29. In May 2009, the Phnom Penh police began again to forcibly round up sex workers and
other poor people “to clean the streets” and take them to rehabilitation centres ahead of a
high-level summit with the European Union. The Ministry of Social Affairs did not participate in
these actions and respected the principle of voluntarism set out in its August 2008 policy.
OHCHR is exploring with the Ministry further solutions to address the difficult issue of poor
people living on the streets.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents