A/HRC/13/43
international protection mechanisms can contribute to strengthen mechanisms at the
national level; the positive expectations at the national and regional levels should not be
ignored; exhaustion of domestic remedies is necessary but only when they are effective and
available and the proceedings are not unduly prolonged; national institutions should be
empowered to bring children-related cases to court; and the need to further discuss the issue
of collective complaints in connection with the future communications procedure.
VII. The unique nature of the rights of the child and specific
rights from the Convention on the Rights of the Child,
including the right of the child to be heard
60.
The topic on the unique nature of the rights of the child and specific rights from the
Convention was introduced by Marta Santos Pais, Special Representative of the SecretaryGeneral on Violence against Children, and Jean Zermatten, Vice-Chairman of the
Committee on the Rights of the Child. Ms. Santos Pais stated that the wealth of experience
developed over 20 years, including a change towards the perception of children as rightsholders, relevant institutional and legal reforms and a comprehensive evaluation of the
work of regional and national mechanisms, could provide useful guidance to the discussion.
61.
Ms. Santos Pais explained how a communications procedure would be relevant for
her mandate. As the Secretary-General’s Study on Violence against Children showed,
violence against children persisted, often as a hidden phenomenon largely accepted by
society. As a result, children feared reporting, particularly in the absence of effective
remedies at the national level. It was therefore essential that appropriate mechanisms be
established at the national level, to be further complemented by a communications
procedure under the Convention, as recommended in the Study. While building on existing
international norms and standards, that procedure would: contribute to the preservation of
the holistic nature of the Convention; take into account the general principles of the
Convention in the consideration of allegations; propose measures to prevent the child from
being subjected to reprisals for having submitted complaints; apply a gender-sensitive
approach; guarantee the right of the child to be heard in proceedings affecting him or her;
and complement the reporting function of the Committee, which would thus be in a position
to call on relevant bodies to support countries in any follow-up to its recommendations,
including by addressing root causes of violence against children.
62.
More specific reasons in favour of an optional protocol establishing a
communications procedure include providing detailed guidance to States on specific
legislative measures, as well as giving the right of the child to information a more specific
content. National mechanisms should be set up to assist individuals in the use of the
procedure, for instance through ombudsman offices. It is essential to ensure that all relevant
actors become knowledgeable and skilful in the use of the procedure.
63.
For a communications procedure to be effective and genuinely accessible to
children, it needed to be understood and made easily available. For this reason, the new
optional protocol could include valuable guidance to States on the need: to provide children
with relevant information on existing complaint mechanisms and procedures; to raise
awareness of what these instruments mean and how they could be used; and to employ
child-sensitive language, materials and tools in the performance of these tasks.
64.
The optional protocol should also recognize important legal safeguards, including
the child’s entitlement to initiate a communications procedure and to be supported
effectively throughout the process; the right of the child to benefit from legal counsel and
representation; the right to free legal aid; and the right to expeditious decisions. Moreover,
the admissibility of a communication should be considered in the light of the best interest of
12
GE.10-10385
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents