A/HRC/36/48
personal intimacy. Technology may also allow older persons to develop remote relations
without the risk of others invading private moments.
56.
A collateral concern of privacy relates to information about the functioning of
devices, such as algorithms, particularly in the event of their potential misuse or
malfunctioning, which could cause harm to users. In such instances, privacy should not be
used as a pretext by developers and companies not to disclose information, on the grounds
that it is sensitive, if it is required to establish responsibility, including negligence or to
challenge driven or automatic decision-making. Again, personal information should only be
disclosed if necessary for a specific, well-defined purpose, bearing in mind that not every
investigation of every form of malfunctioning would justify interference with privacy rights
and that it would be necessary to strike a balance among conflicting rights.
4.
Equality and non-discrimination
57.
Non-discrimination is an immediate and cross-cutting human rights obligation. Age
is a prohibited ground in several contexts, but because of the lack of a clear prohibition of
age discrimination in all aspects of society, age-based distinctions are often considered
legitimate or even necessary.
58.
States must ensure that all older persons enjoy equal access to assistive technology
without discrimination. Eligibility criteria for the provision of assistive devices must follow
a human rights-based approach to ensure that they are not discriminatory. There are, for
instance, age limits in access to disability benefits and mobility allowances that can be used
for the purchase of assistive devices. Such criteria constitute discrimination on the basis of
age and it must therefore be carefully assessed whether, while benefiting certain groups,
they exclude others who have an equal right and comparable need to access the support.
59.
The introduction of advanced assisted technology might amplify the existing gap in
access to such forms of support and also create new inequalities. The affordability of the
system will have an impact on the uptake of technology and therefore equality, inclusion
and the enjoyment of all other human rights (i.e. autonomy), which such technologies are
supposed to enhance.
60.
Special attention needs, moreover, to be paid to older persons who are
disproportionately disadvantaged in terms of access to support, such as migrants, refugees
and asylum seekers, indigenous peoples, ethnic, racial and cultural minorities, stateless
persons, those in conflict or humanitarian situations, and other marginalized segments of
the population. The introduction of assistive technology must not lose sight of those
inequalities.
61.
Furthermore, to be truly inclusive, technology must reflect the diverse preferences
and lifestyles of older persons based on age, disability, nationality, ethnicity, religion,
gender, status, etc. There is some evidence that artificial intelligence could reproduce and
amplify human bias and as a result automated machines could discriminate against some
people. Biased datasets and algorithms may be used in judicial decision-making, medical
diagnoses and other areas that have an impact on older persons’ lives. Auditing machinemade decisions, and their compliance with human rights standards, is therefore considered
necessary to avoid discriminatory treatment.
62.
On the basis of an analysis of the data collected about an older person’s routine and
behaviour, technology may, for instance, detect early signs of Alzheimer’s disease. While
early intervention may be critical in the case of Alzheimer, the older person concerned
should have consented to data being collected for the purpose of making such a diagnosis
and necessary and adequate provisions need to be taken in order to ensure appropriate
preparation for acceptance and a course of action, particularly if he or she does not show
any visible symptoms. If misused, such knowledge could lead to stigmatization of the older
person.
63.
Universal design is intertwined with the right to equality and non-discrimination,
since it is the gateway through which everyone can participate fully and equally in society.
Lack of access to assistive products and services restricts the enjoyment of human rights
that are dependent on support through technology.
12
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents