A/HRC/9/26
page 10
killing and injuring people inside, most residents fled to the street. Once in the street, people
congregated to assist those who had been injured. More shells then landed in the street and
surrounding lanes, killing and injuring dozens more. A number of survivors ran into surrounding
fields. Others indicated running towards the nearby Erez crossing, believing that the Israeli
installation there would offer safety.
28. The testimony received by the mission paints a horrific scene. Woken by the first shell,
families fled their homes and assembled in the street outside, where dead and injured persons
already lay. One mother described being faced with one of her children with an open skull
wound while trying to help another son as he scooped his intestines back into his abdomen.
Another spoke of helping his injured father to the door of the house, only for him to be killed by
a direct shell at the door. As people gathered and attempted to provide assistance to the injured,
more shells landed in the street. There was, according to one witness, “no one left standing”. The
nature of injuries caused by artillery shells meant the street was “strewn with limbs”. Children
were decapitated and a mother worries for her surviving son who “saw his brother cut in half”.
29. Some time after the first shell landed, the injured started to arrive by private vehicle at the
Beit Hanoun hospital, most having lost limbs or requiring amputation. Within a short amount of
time, 30 to 40 injured people arrived at the hospital. The director of the hospital declared an
emergency and called for ambulances from across Gaza to assist. The first ambulance to reach
the scene of the shelling itself came under fire, the driver and assistant being forced to abandon
the vehicle. Footage obtained by the mission of the scene in Beit Hanoun hospital as casualties
from the shelling arrived showed an extremely disturbing scene of a small hospital crowded with
medical staff, victims with blast injuries and their families. Medical staff interviewed by the
mission described not only the trauma in dealing with the onslaught of casualties, but also of
their exhaustion following their efforts during the Autumn Clouds incursion, as described above.
30. The shelling resulted in the immediate death or mortal wounding of 19 civilians, including
seven children and six women. All but one of the victims were from a single family group, the
Al-Athamna. Over 50 others were wounded during the attack.
31. A number of the more seriously injured required treatment that could not be provided in
Gaza. Families of the injured ran directly to the Erez crossing to plead for Israeli approval to
transport injured people to Israeli hospitals. According to survivors, approval to move some
injured to Israeli hospitals was received only some 12 hours after the shelling. Survivors told
how significant obstacles were placed in the way of individuals travelling to Israel for
emergency treatment, in particular:
(a) The refusal by Israeli authorities in some cases to allow the injured to be
accompanied by family members. This was particularly distressing in the case of the elderly and
children who travelled without their closest relatives;
(b) The refusal by Israeli ambulances to transport the injured from Erez crossing to
Israeli hospitals without an immediate payment of some thousands of shekels. These fees were
later reimbursed by the International Committee of the Red Cross.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents