A/HRC/15/29
(b)
In France the State Medical Assistance (Aide Médicale de l’Etat) allows
irregular migrants and their children, who have been residing in France for more than three
months and whose income is below a certain threshold, to access publicly subsidized health
care upon compliance with certain conditions;
(c)
There are explicit references to the right to education for irregular migrants in
the legislation of Belgium, Italy and the Netherlands. In the Netherlands, specific
legislation regarding both primary and secondary school prohibits officials from
investigating a child’s migration status before admission to school.
C.
Detention
82.
Below are examples of recent practice on detention of migrant children:
(a)
In 2005, most children and their family members were released from
Australian immigration detention centres and the Migration Act was amended to affirm “as
a principle” that a minor should only be detained as a measure of last resort;
(b)
In May 2010, the new United Kingdom Government announced an end to the
policy of detaining migrant and asylum-seeking children in detention centres;
(c)
Panama has included in its legislation a prohibition on detaining migrants
who are less than 18 years of age;
(d)
The Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela has explicitly included several
alternatives to detention in its migration legislation including periodic reporting, directed
residence and provision of bail (which takes account of the economic condition of the
migrant).
D.
National jurisprudence
83.
The following show recent practice in national jurisprudence:
(a)
The Constitutional Court of Spain has upheld the right of the child to be
heard in the context of unaccompanied children facing repatriation or deportation;70
(b)
The High Court of South Africa (Transvaal Division) prevented the
deportation in 2004 of a group of unaccompanied migrant children detained in a
repatriation centre. The Court noted that the detention of such children was unlawful and
should cease immediately, observing that “furthermore, the way in which these children are
being deported is not unlawful, it is shameful”.71
E.
Regional jurisprudence
84.
Below are some examples of regional jurisprudence:
(a)
In FIDH v. France,72 the European Committee of Social Rights examined a
complaint based on articles 13 (right to health care) and 17 (rights of the child) of the
European Social Charter, and held that legislation or practice which denies entitlement to
70
71
72
20
Case No. 183/2008 of 22 December 2008.
Case No. 22866/04 of 13 September 2004.
Complaint No. 13/2003.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents