A/HRC/27/73
key provisions related to stereotyping. The issue of stereotyping c ould be analysed
under multiple articles of the Convention, including those addressing the elimination
of all forms of discrimination (art. 2), the obligation to modify gender stereotypes
(art. 5), and the elimination of stereotypes in education (art. 10). She added that the
Convention should be used as a comprehensive, legally binding instrument for the
modification of sex and gender-based stereotypes that constituted discrimination
against women.
7.
Ms. Cusack shared her research on how judicial stereotyping undermined
justice for women, explaining that judicial stereotyping posed a substantial barrier to
justice for women, particularly for victims of gender-based violence. She referred to
the several ways in which judicial stereotyping resulted in miscarriages of justice.
First, it undermined justice by compromising impartiality. I t also influenced judges’
understanding of the nature of criminal offences and their perception of whether
violence had or had not occurred. Stereotyping could further affect judges’ view
about the credibility of witnesses, as well as prevent judges from h olding
perpetrators accountable or even blame the victims for the attack experienced. Th at
harm was continuing to play out and judicial stereotyping was an issue that had to be
addressed if women were to achieve substantive equality.
8.
Ms. Undurraga said that girls were stereotyped and treated as if they were not
(or should not be) interested in sex, so health systems d id not respond to the needs of
girls according to their evolving capacities for autonomous behavio ur. Girls became
exposed to coercion, pregnancies and sexually transmitted diseases. Other
stereotypes included the notion that women were not able to take important decisions
and needed the protection of their husbands or doctors, resulting in women being
denied decision-making autonomy regarding contraception or abortion. The idea that
women should always be available for their husbands denied them the right to decide
when to engage in intercourse and made it difficult for women to win marital rape
cases in courts. Stereotypes that women should sacrifice themselves for their
children have provided the excuse to delay medical treatment to women when such
treatment could affect the foetus. Stereotypes that grounded women’s value on their
fertility or capacity to perform domestic work, sustained practices such as forced
marriage, sexual exploitation and domestic slavery.
9.
Ms. Nigussie, addressing the situation of women with disabilities, reiterated
that in many cases women were expected to be beautiful, fertile and dedicated to
household work, and women with disabilities were regarded as lacking those
attributes. She provided several examples of compounded stereotypes and their
impact on women with disabilities, for instance, in certain places, if a sister of a
woman with disability married, the woman with disability was also “given” to the
husband. In another example, she said that in some communities, HIV-infected men
targeted disabled women in the belief that their purity would cure them of HIV. She
also pointed to the impact of stereotypes in access to justice, explaining that justice
systems did not consider women with disabilities, including victims of violence, as
reliable witnesses, hindering the ability of those women to claim justice. She called
for enhanced efforts to effectively respond to the needs of women with disabilities.
10.
Mr. Minerson, as the moderator, drew attention to the role of stereotypes in
perpetuating certain conceptions of masculinity, and the impact th at had had on
eliminating violence against women. He explained that his organiza tion was
interested in the narrative surrounding masculinity and the way men dealt with
violence, and also in breaking stereotypes of men as violent, aggressive, in control of
money, not nurturing and loving. He stressed that it was important to change the
4
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents