A/HRC/12/37
page 25
between the West Bank and Israeli territory. Israel maintains that checkpoints are vital for
security. However, most of these checkpoints are located well inside the West Bank, up to
several kilometres from the Green Line.102
73. The Wall itself has, as of March 2009, 66 gates. Only half of them are open to Palestinian
use, and then only for holders of a special permit from the Israeli forces. The gates available for
Palestinian use are open only part of the day. In addition to staffed checkpoints, the army has
erected hundreds of physical obstructions (dirt piles, concrete blocks, boulders, trenches, fences
and iron gates) to block access to main roads and channel Palestinian traffic to staffed
checkpoints. In recent years, the number of these obstructions has gradually risen.103
74. Travel on hundreds of kilometres of roads in the West Bank is restricted or prohibited
outright for Palestinians, whereas Israelis are allowed to travel on them freely. As of
March 2009, travel of all Palestinians (apart from East Jerusalem residents, who carry special
identity papers and are entitled to purchase cars with Israeli-issued number plates) is restricted or
prohibited outright on 430 kilometres of roads in the West Bank, while Israelis are allowed to
travel these sections freely. On 137 of the 430 kilometres, the Army prohibits Palestinian travel
completely; on the remainder of the forbidden roads, only Palestinians with permits are allowed
to travel.104
75. In addition, about one third of the West Bank, including occupied East Jerusalem, is
completely prohibited to Palestinians without a special permit issued by the Israeli military. Even
with a special permit, entering these restricted areas with a Palestinian car (i.e. a car with a
Palestinian-issued number plate) is prohibited under all circumstances. On the occasion of
Jewish holidays from 9 through 11 March 2009, the Government of Israel imposed a three-day
closure on the West Bank, prohibiting Palestinians from entering Israel and occupied
East Jerusalem. A similar ban was enforced from 6 through 18 April, again for Jewish holidays.
76. It is difficult to adequately express the wide scope of human rights violations that these
extreme restrictions impose on the Palestinian population. These severe restrictions themselves
amount not only to a violation of the right to freedom of movement,105 but also result in
situations where Palestinians are effectively prevented from exercising other rights, including the
right to work (art. 6 of ICESCR), the right to an adequate standard of living (art. 11), the right to
health (art. 12), and the right to education (article 13). Though comprehensive data do not exist,
thousands of people are effectively prevented on a daily basis from accessing workplaces,
schools and health-care facilities, from purchasing necessary goods and from visiting family
102
B’tselem, “Restrictions on movement”, www.btselem.org/english/Freedom_of_
Movement/Statistics.asp.
103
Ibid.
104
B’Tselem, 2008 Annual Report, p. 13
105
Article 12 of ICCPR states that “[e]veryone lawfully within the territory of a State shall,
within that territory, have the right of liberty of movement”.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents