A/HRC/9/23
page 13
food crisis.21 The statement made by leaders of the Group of eight on global food security makes
no reference to the issue. No governmental delegation present at the High-Level Conference on
World Food Security mentioned agrarian reform or the need to protect the security of land
tenure.22
21. To the extent that the emphasis is on increasing the production of food, the responses to the
current global food crisis could, however, lead to new threats to security of land tenure. One
danger in the current situation is that, as a result of the renewed interest in agriculture and the
race towards the production of agrofuels,23 competition will increase for land in what has been
described as “‘an uneven playing field - in many cases between large-scale investors and local
land users who often hold no statutory rights over the land they use”.24 The development of
transnational investment in agricultural land, by which countries seek to ensure their food
security by buying land abroad, and the development of monocultures for exports increase such
pressure even further. In this context, developing countries should be encouraged to ensure
security of tenure for all land users. While landowners may gain from the increase in the price of
land, it constitutes a threat for landless labourers or for those whose title to the land they
cultivate is insecure, and it may make it impossible for small holders to acquire more land in
order to increase production. Securing land rights would encourage investors seeking to produce
crops for export to opt for contract farming with small-holders, thus contributing to a better
livelihood for the producers concerned.
22. Not only should the rights of land users on their land be secured; excessive concentration
of land should also be avoided, and, where necessary, agrarian reform should be pursued to
ensure that those who depend on land for their livelihood have access to it. Article 11(2) (a) of
the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights refers to developing or
reforming agrarian systems as a means of ensuring the fundamental right to be free from hunger.
Agrarian reforms should be accelerated, as recommended by Guideline 8.10 of the FAO
Guidelines on the Right to Food and by the FAO International Conference on Agrarian Reform
21
The Latin American Presidential Summit, at which 15 delegations were convened
on 7 May 2008 in Managua, did express its support for ‘an agrarian reform process, that would
provide land to agricultural producers who are currently deprived of this resource to produce
food’(‘un proceso de reforma agraria, que provea de tierras a aquellos productores agrícolas, que
en este momento no tienen este recurso para producir alimentos’).
22
See International Land Coalition, Access to land and the food crisis: Feedback and reflections
by the ILC Secretariat on the FAO High Level Conference on World Food Security, June 2008,
www.landcoalition.org.
23
Fuelling Exclusion? The Biofuel Boom and Poor People's Access to Land, by Lorenzo Cotula,
Nat Dyer and Sonja Vermeulen, www.iied.org/pubs/pdfs/12551IIED.pdf.
24
International Land Coalition, Access to land and the food crisis, cited above.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents